The Best Dating Apps in Amarillo that Experts Actually Use in 2023

Dating in a city like Amarillo isn't easy. We know this from experience. As a popular stop along Route 66, you get a handful of daytrippers checking out the sights, which can be fun sometimes. But when it comes to people who'll stick around long enough, is everyone either taken in Amarillo or moving to other nearby cities to find love or something more casual? It sure seems like it until you try the top dating apps in Amarillo, Texas.

If you're tired of the small-town dating scene in Amarillo, you may be tempted to make the drive to Lubbock to meet new people. You might even make it as far as Fort Worth if you're serious about improving your dating odds. We're here to tell you that you can put that road trip on hold because online dating will make your life much easier.

Below are some of the best dating apps and sites in Amarillo that will help you meet someone special. Instead of going to the same old bars or hoping you meet someone cool at work, try these apps and you can expand that proverbial dating net.

#1 - Singles looking for a serious relationship use eHarmony

eHarmony iOS

If you're a guy looking for a woman who's here to stay, eHarmony gives you the best odds of meeting her. The male to female ratio on eHarmony is quite reasonable (52 % to 48%), which is way better than Tinder's (8:2). This makes it so much easier to match up with women and actually be selective about who you want to go on a date with.

eHarmony company takes matchmaking pretty seriously. It was the first to use algorithms to generate personalized matches based on users' preferences and filters, and now it uses a set of short questions to connect you with like-minded singles in Amarillo and anywhere in the country. It's also been proven that almost 70% of users who use eHarmony for just one year end up meeting their future spouse. So we highly recommend eHarmony as one of the best dating apps in Amarillo.

What we liked about eHarmony

  • You’re almost guaranteed to find a long-term partner within a few months of signing up
  • Plenty of compatible, and attractive matches
  • Great male-to-female ratio

What we didn’t like about eHarmony

  • Having to answer a ton of questions is a bit tedious
  • Not the best for young singles who just want casual hookups



#2 - Christian Mingle is one of the top dating apps in Amarillo for religious singles

Christian Mingle iOS

The name says it all. A faith-based community of serious singles who want to date for long-term relationships. Christian Mingle is one of the biggest Christian dating networks on the planet with more than 15 million active users. It may not be popular in New York or Miami, but it's a thing in the Bible Belt states and here in Texas.

The site uses your filters, along with your denomination - Catholic, Protestant, Orthodox, and more -, and your favorite church to connect you with single Christians whose faith plays an important role in their lives. Check out Christian Mingle now if you want a lover who supports your faith.

What we liked about Christian Mingle

  • Risk-free – You get a 10-day free trial before being asked to upgrade
  • Takes compatibility seriously
  • Perfect for Christians who want to meet someone of the same faith

What we didn’t like

  • You have to fill in a lot of details about yourself which takes time
  • No place for non-religious people and singles from other religions



#3 - AFF is the best way to meet fun-loving locals for casual fun (try it free here)


This may not be your typical dating site, but it's getting a lot of buzz in Amarillo. AFF is known for attracting those who are looking for casual fun and nothing more (check out their free trial here to see). It's been around for quite some time but doesn't get the attention it deserves, mainly because those who use it are often discreet about what they use it for.

AFF isn't just another mindless hookup site where you try to set up a date with anyone that looks remotely hot. It has some pretty advanced search filters so that you can meet people who are into the same things you are. Whatever your preference behind closed doors, AFF has a filter for it. And along with those filters are a bunch of users who'll give as much as they get!

What we liked about AFF

  • You don’t need a lot of time to move from texting to dating
  • Respectful but unfiltered
  • Focused on hookups

What we didn’t like about it

  • The user interface looks outdated
  • No dedicated app, but you can access it via a mobile browser
You Can Try AFF Free!
If you're just looking for a fling or more short-term fun you need to try out AFF's free trial. We've spent months and months testing out the alternatives (more than 100 other sites) and haven't found anything that gives most guys more options and better results. Give it a shot!


#4 - Who isn't on Tinder these days?

Tinder iOS screenshots

No list of top dating apps will be complete without Tinder. What can we say? It's popular, free, and fun to use! Tinder has become a household name in the dating world because so many singles are hooked on it. Just a word of caution, though: temper those expectations.

While there are lots of people you can potentially match with on Tinder, it doesn't always make it easy. Most of the hottest users (those who others always swipe right on) are spoiled for choice. That means they only swipe right on guys they really find attractive. If you're a little more average joe and a little less A&F underwear model, your best strategy is to take some great photos to really stand out. Since Tinder is very looks-based, you need eye-catching photos to get more right swipes.

What we liked about Tinder

  • Everyone is using it
  • The sign-up process is pretty easy
  • It’s fun to use

What we didn’t like about Tinder

  • You won’t get plenty of good matches if you’re not hot
  • Because of the huge attention they get, Tinder girls tend to ignore guys pretty easily



#5 - Coffee Meets Bagel is for serious Amarillo daters

Coffee Meets Bagel on Android

In case you want something serious or long-term, and you just moved to Amarillo, Coffee Meets Bagel is here to serve. The company markets itself as "the best app for meaningful dating." This is because they focus on quality over quantity.


Unlike on Tinder where you get a fairly large number of swipes (or unlimited if you pay a premium), you only get five daily suggestions on Coffee Meets Bagel. The app uses your information, filters, and preferences to connect you with like-minded people, then sends five new matches your way every single night.

This may not sound like a lot (and it's true), but plenty of users found such compatibility to be valuable. You get to focus on each of your matches, which makes it easier to get to know each other and arrange a date.

What we liked about Coffee Meets Bagel

  • It’s high on compatibility
  • Very popular in Texas
  • Users are serious about meeting up

What we didn’t like

  • Gives you a limited number of swipes every day
  • You might give up on the app if you don’t get decent matches within a week of signing up



The Best Dating Sites in Amarillo for Long-Term Relationships

A couple kissing in a park

People have different preferences. Despite what the pickup industry promotes, some guys do want a happy, long-term relationship. If that's you, then we have something for you. We tested the market for the best relationships out there, and below are the two best dating apps in Amarillo for long-term relationships. Here they are:

eHarmony is the best site for making meaningful connections

The best thing about eHarmony is that you usually only need to use it for 6-12 months to find your next girlfriend/wife. This may sound like a lot but it isn't. The company claims to be responsible for 4% of America's yearly marriages, which translates into 524 marriages every day thanks to the app. According to a recent report, almost 70% of eHarmony users met their perfect long-term match (boy/girlfriend, or spouse) within a year of using the app.

The app is high on compatibility vs. looks. It uses the questions you answer to connect you with like-minded women who share similar values with you and are more likely to get along with you.

Bumble is for those who want to try something new

Bumble is pretty much like Tinder but with one key difference: you don't get to text women on Bumble even if when you match with them. She gets 24 hours to choose whether to text you or not. These filters and rules were the reason many women flock to Bumble every year to the degree that it became the second most popular dating app in the country (34% market share).

I use Bumble a lot and tried it in different countries. I even met my last two girlfriends on it. You'll like it whether you want something casual or a relationship, but you'll notice that the majority of its users are busy women (mid-20s and 30s) who don't have time to meet their next boyfriend offline. If that's your cup of tea, then give Bumble a try. It may work for you.

The Best Hookup Sites in Amarillo

Blonde woman on a plush carpet

Choosing the best hookup app can be tough. Many hookup apps use men's lust to milk them for money using fake accounts and cam girls. The majority of hookup apps you'll find are either useless or way too expensive. But the good news? We found a few that actually work. Including these two:

AFF makes finding hookups a breeze

Unlike many popular apps, AFF is all about hookups. Every user is here to have fun and fun only. We didn't see any body-shaming on the app or flakiness. If you like someone, and they like you back, there's a big chance they won't flake on you when the time comes for a meetup.

AFF has plenty of fans in Amarillo. We had a bunch of friends who met gorgeous women on AFF even though they (our friends) weren't as hot as you'd expect. Probably because people tend to be less picky about their flings than when choosing their long-term partners. We liked AFF, and in case you want to give it a shot, check out their free trial to see for yourself.

If you’re young and hot, Tinder is for you

In case you don't know, Tinder started as a hookup app ten years ago before turning into everybody's favorite dating app. The app is image-based and, in a place like Texas, it's hard to date hot women on Tinder if you don't have model-like looks.

However, the sheer volume of people using the app makes your odds for meeting someone hot pretty high. Just make sure to show your selected Tinder photos to a bunch of female friends before uploading them. This is one of the times when seeking women for dating advice actually works.

The Best Free Dating Sites in Amarillo

Browsing through free dating apps

Can you meet women on dating apps without spending a dime?

Yes, and no.

With a few good photos, and a well-written bio you can get by on any dating app or site for absolutely nothing. Ask anyone who uses free dating apps regularly and they will confirm. But this doesn't mean that premium features and boosts won't improve the quality and quantity of your matches.

My advice?

Start with a bunch of free but popular, apps until you get better at texting women. Once you go on a few dates, I suggest upgrading to premium, while also updating your photos. That's the best way to 10x your success online.

And, in case you're wondering, these are our best free dating apps and sites in Amarillo:

  • OkCupid
  • Bumble
  • Tinder

Give these apps a try to improve your skills. Once you've mastered the art of texting women, you could up the ante by actually signing up for a paid dating app. With these apps, you usually get better matchmaking results and in turn, much better dates.

Join Our Newsletter

No Spam. Just Higher Dating Success.

Leave a Comment