When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

The Top 5 Dating Apps in Buffalo That Are Working in 2024

A woman picking a match from a Buffalo dating app

Have you found that choosing dating apps in Buffalo, NY is more difficult than ever? With so many platforms to choose from and so many online dating guides that claim to know the answer to finding the right partner (they don’t), it’s frustrating to get real expert advice if you want to find success - and Beyond Ages is here to help men and women in Buffalo find the best relationship(s) they can.

Trust us, dating has changed. In the past, hitting up some of the biggest bars in Buffalo (like Buffalo Tap House and The Old Pink) was virtually a slam dunk when it came to finding love or a steamy new hookup. Or, maybe you’re studying at the University of Buffalo and it was inevitable that you’d find someone sooner or later…

The truth is that there’s no match for the number of people you can meet on a dating app or free dating sites in Buffalo.

To make matters worse, modern interaction has drastically changed. The COVID-19 pandemic permanently changed the way people date in Buffalo and surrounding areas. With Buffalo continuing to adjust to this “new normal”, there are plenty more factors to consider when meeting new people, including their health choices, lifestyle, dating arrangements, career, and more.

As dating becomes more and more online-oriented due to people getting more familiar with using apps to meet (and screen) new exciting partners, it’s only natural to want to discover the best dating sites in Buffalo for a competitive advantage.

The 5 Best Dating Sites in Buffalo Right Now

Not all dating apps are created equal. Nor does every dating app work the same for guys in Buffalo. To help you get the best success when it comes to online dating, we chose the 5 best dating sites based on our experience using them.

In the next section, you’ll discover our 5 best dating site recommendations for Buffalo. Let’s begin!

#1 - eHarmony (Android, iOS) is one of the best dating apps in Buffalo for long-term relationships

eHarmony iOS

eHarmony is your best choice in Buffalo for long-term compatible matches. To start, eHarmony is not a dating app that’s designed to help you set up hookups or casual encounters. Instead, eHarmony requires all users to complete a fairly detailed and lengthy questionnaire that includes their preferences, interests, and hobbies. Just by the questionnaire alone, most timewasters and those seeking short-term romance are screened out.

Second, the questionnaire sends you match recommendations based on your compatibility - users don’t get to pick from an endless pool of bad matches. This might seem different Considering that 7 out of 10 users find their future spouse within a year on the app. The algorithm really works! eHarmony has free and paid subscriptions, so be sure to explore this app and find the love you deserve.

Why eHarmony is one of the best long-term dating sites in Buffalo

  • Best success rate out for long-term relationships among all dating apps
  • Compatibility is a priority on the app, not just looks
  • Designed for serious users who know what they want
  • Less scam and spam profiles than other apps

Drawbacks about eHarmony

  • Requires a pretty large time investment to start
  • Not popular with younger demographics



#2 - Plenty of Fish (Android, iOS) is a great way for singles to meet in Buffalo

Plenty of Fish Android

Among dating apps in Buffalo, Plenty of Fish (PoF) has gotten an undeserved reputation in the past for being second-rate. From its clunky design to its relatively smaller pool of users, PoF just seemed like it was no match for eHarmony, Tinder, and the like…

Well, think again. In truth, PoF is actually a goldmine for women that are tired of dealing with the headaches and intense competition on other apps, plenty of scam profiles, and paid features that don’t work. PoF puts you in touch with users that feel the same way, giving you access to a more discerning user base. Plus, paid memberships - known on PoF as “Upgraded Profiles” - let users add up to 16 pictures, get a boost in the rankings, enable you to see who browsed your profile, and much more!

Why PoF is great

  • Less competition
  • Paid features give you way more functionality than other apps

What we don’t like about PoF

  • May not have top-tier profiles that gravitate to other popular apps
  • The interface feels like a knock-off of other apps



#3 - AFF is the best dating site in Buffalo for casual sexy relationships (try it free here)

AFF homepage

From your laptop to your lap, matching results in Buffalo is simple and straightforward with AFF! As the name implies, everyone on the app is here to hook up and have NSA fun!

What makes AFF a great choice is its variety. With 60+ million users, you won’t be disappointed with searching for someone in Buffalo who knows what they want in the bedroom. AFF’s profiles go beyond the guesswork and ambiguity that other “hookup”-type apps feature, like Tinder. Instead of endless swiping, users can tailor their searches based on a number of attributes: location, age, preferences, body type, and more.

Best of all, you can use the app’s free trial to get a feel for it, then pay the relatively-cheap membership fee to really jump into the deep end. Pro tip: Get the paid membership and get the frisky fun you want - why wait?!

Why AFF is great for Buffalo hookups

  • A huge pool of active users
  • Straightforward interface
  • Plenty of searches, broad profiles, interactions, and other choices
  • Webcam options to help verify partners and set expectations-before meeting in-person

What we don’t like about AFF

  • Can be a bit of a meat market
  • Highly competitive for vanilla interests
You Can Try AFF Free!
If you're just looking for more short-term fun you need to try out AFF. We've spent months and months testing out the alternatives (more than 100 other sites) and haven't found anything that gives most guys more options and better results. Give it a shot!


#4 - Tinder (Android, iOS) is a great way for singles to meet in Buffalo

Tinder iOS screenshots

Tinder is the most popular dating app in Buffalo - and with good reason. If you’re looking to find singles for hookups and long-term relationships (and some other sexy pairings), using Tinder puts all the women in your area at your fingertips. Simply swipe left to weed out bad matches, tap to see more photos, and swipe right to start matching to begin the conversion.

But let’s be honest: Tinder’s reliance on pictures means this is an app that’s all about how attractive you are. Based on an “ELO” rating, Tinder’s algorithm will try to pair you with women that are more in line with your looks and common interests, so it may come as a shock or pleasant surprise to be matched with women you find attractive (or not).

As it’s so easy to use, Tinder is one of the fastest ways to go on dates without the endless back-and-forth that comes with other dating apps in Buffalo. Best-suited for smartphones, Tinder is available for desktops and tablets, too.

Why Tinder is great for men in Buffalo

  • Largest pool of potential romantic partners and hookups
  • Easy-to-use platform
  • Unlimited swipes for paid memberships

What we don’t like about Tinder

  • Lots of competition
  • Predominantly a looks-based app, so it can be hard to make meaningful connections
  • Paid memberships that actually get results are expensive



#5 - Hinge helps guys increase their pool of dates and hookups

Hinge Android features

Hinge may not seem like the first choice when it comes to dating apps in Buffalo, but that’s precisely the point. Avoid the heavy competition, as well as plenty of scammers and spammers by using Hinge. With 6 million active users, you’re likely to have some overlap with other apps and most likely meet other, dating “refugees” that are tired of Tinder’s superficiality, Bumble’s women-centric approach or Coffee Meets Bagel’s elitism.

Plus, Hinge has some of its own features that other apps lack. These include “icebreaker” questions and the photo prompt feature that lets you add a little bit of humor to your photos. Hinge’s paid features (“Preferred Membership”) are also great for unlimited likes, extra roses, extra gifts, and much more

Why Hinge is one of the best dating apps in Buffalo for men

  • Unique user base
  • User profiles are more in-depth than other apps
  • Less competition and superficiality

What we don’t like about Hinge

  • The free version is very much just a test drive; you’ll need to pay to get the full benefits
  • There is no desktop version
  • The UX leaves a lot more to be desired



The Best Hookup Sites in Buffalo

A woman smiling in bed

Of all the best Buffalo hookup sites for getting down, only AFF and Tinder really fit the bill. Here’s why:

AFF is the discreet choice for NSA fun

Buffalo accounts for a much smaller area than you may realize - and you may not want everyone to know your business. so it’s great to know that AFF protects your privacy and only enables users to engage those who are serious about having fun (get it?). This is especially important if you’re looking for specific fetishes or keep your swinging lifestyle discreet, which is why AFF is a great choice.

Tinder is synonymous with “hookup”

Tinder is a hookup app, plain and simple. And Buffalo has a younger demographic that loves to hook up. Therefore, use Tinder!

If you want to meet a woman almost on-demand, Tinder literally puts her in the palm of your hand, making it a cinch to swipe on attractive ladies, match immediately, and begin chatting to see what she’s looking for. Just make sure your photos are on point, otherwise you probably won't get a ton of matches.

The Best Dating Sites in Buffalo for Serious Relationships

A couple in a cabin

Let’s take a look at why eHarmony and Plenty of Fish are the best dating sites/apps in Buffalo for finding relationships.

eHarmony = Success

Considering Buffalo is one of the best cities in the US to meet other college-educated singles, eHarmony is a natural choice for the city’s growing career-oriented demographic. With an intuitive design and emphasis on quality matches, eHarmony is one of the best dating apps in Buffalo that actually works.

Plenty of Fish, plenty of options

When it comes to Buffalo dating sites, not all users are on all platforms. Plenty of Fish gives you another chance to find women that may not be on another app. Plus, PoF’s interface is similar to other dating apps, so it’s easy to use right out of the box.

The Best Free Dating Apps in Buffalo

Texting while having coffee

Listen, modern dating is hard. And dating apps are meant to make it easier. There are plenty of good things about dating apps in Buffalo, like accessing a wider group of women in your area. However, there are plenty of cons, such as expensive membership fees that simply don’t get results.

That being said, you’re like to get better results if you pay for using an app - it’s their business model, after all. Think of it like paying a cover fee at a hot nightclub for access to better women versus just hitting up a trashy dive bar that’s too crowded. You’re essentially paying for better access, and finding love and/or hookups is a bargain for just about any popular dating app.

We’ve covered a bunch of free dating apps in Buffalo. In addition to those mentioned, here are a few more free dating apps that can help you get the love you want:

  • Hinge
  • Coffee Meets Bagel
  • Hily

Best of luck!

Join Our Newsletter

No Spam. Just Higher Dating Success.

Leave a Comment