The Top 5 Dating Apps in Indiana in 2023 Recommended by Dating Coaches

A woman using an Indiana dating app while making dinner

It’s okay to say it: Most dating apps in Indiana these days suck. Dealing with poor matches, spam profiles, expensive memberships that don’t work, and a small active user base of available women - the struggle is real when all you want is to meet up with a woman in real life!

In the past, simply living in Indiana's best cities - like Bloomington, Indianapolis, and Evansville - was nearly a guarantee to find some new love interest or a short-term fling for the summer. Or, maybe you’re studying at Ivy Tech Community College or Purdue University and it felt like it was only a matter of time before you found someone sooner or later.

Sadly, that was the past and this is now. But, don’t fret just yet, there is hope if you use the top Indiana dating apps and websites to deal with all of the new challenges that come with today’s dating paradigm.

We are here by your side to make it as easy as possible to decide on the best Indiana dating apps and sites.

There are a ton of singles using dating apps in Indiana

Indiana gender breakdown

The average percentage of single people in the US is around 28.3%. In Indiana, it's 30.38%--not a ton more, but definitely up there when compared to other states. The great thing about this is that Indiana has a population of over 6.8 million people with over 1 million single women and 1 million single men. On top of that, there are about 22,000 more single women than there are men.

If you're thinking that the same old watering holes and hangouts are only full of dudes, then you might be looking in all the wrong places. Instead of going out every single day to meet women, our suggestion is to try some of the state's top dating apps.

The 5 Best Dating Sites in Indiana Right Now

We rated each of the 5 best dating sites in Indiana by the most important criteria for dating success:

  • How popular each app is in Indiana
  • How the apps fits the unique culture of the entire state (including the largest cities, suburbs, and rural areas)
  • UX/UI design features
  • Free membership features versus paid subscription features
  • And more

With these criteria in mind, the next five (5) recommendations will help you find the best dating app in Indiana. Let’s begin!

#1 - eHarmony (Android, iOS) ranks among the best dating apps in Indiana for singles looking for serious relationships

Android eHarmony

Looking for a long-term commitment? Then eHarmony is your best choice for dating apps in Indiana.

The reason for this is that eHarmony uses an entirely different method of matching than other swipe-oriented dating apps you might be familiar with:

  • First, eHarmony starts off with a questionnaire that’s pretty lengthy and detailed. However, this helps you find a more compatible match AND screens out people who aren’t serious about finding commitment.
  • Second, eHarmony isn’t free (though it’s pretty affordable). This also helps screen out those who are more wishy-washy about what they want out of the Indiana dating market. Plus, this makes for a better experience, especially for women who are usually bombarded by plenty of “thirsty” guys.
  • Third, users who choose to stick with eHarmony have a 70% chance of getting married within 1 year of using this dating site. It’s hard to beat those odds in the current Indiana dating scene!

Try eHarmony and see the difference for yourself today!

Here’s why eHarmony is so awesome:

  • Best success rate for long-term relationships
  • The eHarmony algorithm uniquely pairs you with real matches based on shared interests
  • Screen out the time-wasters before you actually start chatting with single women in Indiana

Drawbacks to using eHarmony’s platform:

  • It’s not free
  • Requires a significant upfront time investment to start using the app correctly
  • Users cannot search for matches
  • Not as popular with younger female demographics



#2 - Coffee Meets Bagel (iOS, Android) helps you meet young and professional women

Coffee Meets Bagel iOS

As one of the fastest-growing states for young professionals, Indiana attracts plenty of career-oreinted individuals and those who like the finer things in life. To meet women that fall in this demographic, it makes sense to use an app geared towards dating these demographics.

To meet these women, Coffee Meets Bagel (CMB) is the right choice. Designed with career-oriented professionals in mind, CMB features a better way to meet women using their “beans” system. Earn beans daily during the free trial period and use these as a way to like profiles (or simply like their profile and wait for a mutual match). Paid memberships enable users to purchase beans and Discover Likes, which are like “Super Likes” on other platforms.

Coffee Meets Bagel gives you daily updates around lunchtime (12 PM) or after work (6 - 9 PM) when matches are most likely to set up a date after work, and enough discoverability features to find the match near you, CMB simply makes sense for Indiana men who’ve got something going on with their lives.

What makes Coffee Meets Bagel one of the best serious dating apps in Indiana:

  • Upscale user base
  • Much less competition versus other apps
  • Set filters for race, age, location, religion, and other deal-breakers ahead of time

What should be improved on CMB:

  • There are fewer women on the platform than on other dating apps in Indiana
  • The free trial only lasts a week before limiting your chance to like other profiles
  • Discoverability won’t let you set distances between large increments (ex. 25 miles to 50 miles)



#3 - AFF is the best dating site in Indiana for finding a casual relationship (try it free)


AFF is the best dating site for Indiana men that want to find some casual relationships with no strings attached. And because everyone on AFF is here to have some steamy fun, you won’t need to worry about the awkwardness that’s so common on other Indiana dating apps.

With 60+ million users, you’ll have no problem searching among Indiana women that are looking for exactly what you are into. Featuring a highly-specific search function, you’ll find plenty of filters to find women that want the same preferences in the bedroom and other aspects so you can have the most fun. Best of all, AFF offers a generous free trial, but most Indiana men that see the best rate of success on AFF pony up the cash to really kick start their love life.

Why AFF is so good:

  • Huge active user base
  • Fewer people are looking for an ego boost and attention than other apps
  • Well-designed interface
  • Plenty of privacy features to keep your dating life a well-kept secret
  • Webcam options for those that want to set expectations before meeting up in-person

What might be improved on AFF:

  • Most users only access AFF via the web app
  • AFF can feel like a “meat market”
  • The free trial will leave you wanting more
You Can Try AFF Free!
If you're just looking for more short-term fun you need to try out AFF. We've spent months and months testing out the alternatives (more than 100 other sites) and haven't found anything that gives most guys more options and better results. Give it a shot!


#4 - Plenty of Fish (Android, iOS) has plenty of singles looking for all sorts of arrangements

Plenty of Fish Android

If you’re looking to start chatting by video instead of endless back and forth messaging then Plenty of Fish (PoF) is the right choice for men in Indiana.

While PoF has all of the familiar swipe features like Tinder and other apps, the app really shines with its Live feature. Start chatting with women in real-time to build a real connection that texting simply won’t achieve. If you’re comfortable with making witty banter and engaging conversation, PoF is the app for you.

Beyond the Live feature, PoF is free to start swiping, but it also has a paid option called “Upgraded Profiles”. By paying a small upfront cost (cheaper than most apps), you can add up to 16 pics, and enable you to see who browsed your profile, and much more!

Why Plenty of Fish is a great dating app:

  • Unique user base, so there’s less competition than other apps
  • The Live feature avoids endless texting and ghosting
  • Paid subscription features give you more functionality than other dating apps

Plenty of Fish needs to improve the following:

  • May not have as many top-tier profiles and attractive women as other popular dating apps
  • Interface feels a bit overcrowded and overwhelming



#5 - Christian Mingle (Android, iOS) is a great app for Christian singles looking for a committed partnership

Christian Mingle Android

45% of Indiana residents report themselves as religious. With nearly half of the state’s population making faith a part of their lives, Christian Mingle is the best option in Indiana.

Everyone on Christian Mingle is a practicing Christian, so you can be sure that you’re interacting with women that have similar morals and values. Best of all, Christian Mingle is a free dating app, so it’s perfectly fine to test the waters first before upgrading to a paid subscription. With more than 15 million active users - many of them based in Indiana - you’re certain to find a partner that shares your Christian beliefs.

Why you should try it:

  • Plenty of free features to get a feel for the app
  • Subscriptions enable great features like Read Receipts, enhanced Privacy Controls, and more
  • Easy to use on desktop computers and smartphones

Why Christian Mingle isn’t always the best option:

  • A fairly limited dating pool
  • Free memberships offer only limited messaging options, so you may not get results until you pay for a membership
  • There are plenty of denominations of Christianity, so it may be hard to find a 100% match



The Best Hookup Sites in Indiana

Sexy brunette woman with a tattoo

Of all the best Indiana hookup sites, only AFF and Tinder really get the result you’re looking for. Here’s why:

AFF knows what you want

If keeping things casual is the way you like it when dating, then AFF should be the first site you try. It's full of singles all looking for the same thing: hot encounters with no strings attached. Try out their multitude of features to help you get in touch with other singles. You'll find that hooking up online is so much easier on AFF than on any other app.

Tinder basically means casual dating

Tinder is definitely one of the most popular dating apps in Indiana, this is why users flock to the app to find hookups. Pro tip: Get a paid subscription membership to send 5 Super Likes per day and beat out the other guys looking for sexy fun.

The Best Dating Sites in Indiana for Serious Relationships

A married couple walking through a field

Our first choice for long-term dating is eHarmony, you simply can’t go wrong with the app, knowing that it boasts a very high success rate. If you want another option, Match is our second recommendation.

Let’s take a look at why eHarmony and Match are among the best dating sites in Indiana you’ll find.

eHarmony helps you get real results

eHarmony makes finding a real match quite easy, simply answer the detailed questionnaire and stay on the app. Soon enough, you’ll receive recommendations that are compatible with you. Start messaging right away and you’ll see just how powerful the eHarmony algorithm really is!

Match has a reputation for a reason

Match will pair you with a compatible match, this is simply because they have been around for nearly three decades. So it’s safe to say that they know a thing or two about online dating. Try it out if eHarmony hasn't worked out for you.

The Best Free Dating Apps in Indiana

Showing her friends a free dating app she's using

There’s no such thing as a free lunch when it comes to online dating in Indiana.

While we all love to get something for nothing, the saying “you get what you pay for” is also true in dating apps. Subscribing to a paid membership gives you a leg up on your dating app adventure. That being said, free dating apps can give you some success if you’re really attractive (of course you are!), good at flirty banter, or just have luck on your side.

Besides the dating apps we’ve recommended in this article so far, the following apps are also some of the best free Indiana dating apps that we recommend:

  • Hinge
  • Bumble
  • OkCupid

And as a last reminder: Don’t be discouraged if an app isn’t exactly to your liking. Try a different app and see if that fits the bill. As with anything related to modern dating in Indiana, patience is key to finding a hookup, a hot date, or a long-term commitment (and maybe all three!). Good luck out there!

Join Our Newsletter

No Spam. Just Higher Dating Success.

Leave a Comment