When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

The Top 9 Toledo Dating Apps and Sites Dating Coaches Recommend in 2024

Using the best Toledo hookup apps to find a date this evening

Have you found that choosing dating apps in Toledo, Ohio is more difficult than you initially thought?

With so many platforms to choose from and so many dating advice guides that claim to know the answer to finding the right partner, it’s certainly a challenge to get real expert advice if you want to find dating success - and BeyondAges is here to help men and women in Toledo find the best relationship(s) they can.

Trust us, dating has changed. In the past, hitting up some of the biggest bars in Toledo (like The Heights and Wesley's Bar & Grill) was virtually a slam dunk when it came to finding love or a steamy new hookup. Or, maybe you’re studying at the University of Toledo and it was inevitable that you’d find someone sooner or later…

The truth is that there’s no match for the number of people you can meet on a dating app or free dating sites in Toledo.

To make matters worse, modern interaction has changed. The COVID-19 pandemic permanently changed the way people date in the area. With Toledo still adjusting to the “new normal”, there are even more factors to consider when meeting new people, including their health choices, lifestyle, dating arrangements, career, and more.

As dating becomes more and more online-oriented due to people getting more familiar with using apps to meet (and screen) new exciting partners, it’s only natural to want to discover the best dating sites in Toledo for a competitive advantage.

The 5 Best Dating Sites in Toledo, Ohio Right Now

To help you get the best success when it comes to online dating, we chose the 5 best dating sites in Toledo based on their popularity, how easy they are to use, and how quickly we could find a date.

#1 - eHarmony (Android, iOS) is one of the best dating apps in Toledo for success in finding a long-term relationship

eHarmony iOS

eHarmony is extremely popular in Toledo for long-term compatible matches and has been since it’s inception. Why? First off, eHarmony isn’t designed for hookups like other dating apps aimed at Toledo are (:cough: Tinder: cough:). Instead, eHarmony requires all users to complete a LENGTHY questionnaire about their preferences, interests, hobbies, and more. Just by the sheer detail of the questionnaire alone, most people seeking casual encounters are screened out.

Second, eHarmony’s one-of-a-kind questionnaire sends you match recommendations based on your compatibility - not just alluring pics that only scratch the surface of what a person is really about. Considering that an astonishing 70% of users find their future spouse within a year on eHarmony (you read that right: marriage!), the eHarmony algorithm works!

eHarmony has both free and paid subscription models, so be sure to fully explore this app and get the best results your romantic life deserves.

Why eHarmony remains one of the best dating sites in Toledo

  • Best success rate out for serious relationships among every other dating apps
  • Makes it pretty easy to form connections based on shared interests
  • Designed for serious users that want romance, not a waste of time
  • Less scam and spam profiles than other apps

What we don’t necessarily like about eHarmony

  • The questionnaire requires a significant time investment
  • Not popular with younger demographics looking to explore casual relationships



#2 - Christian Mingle (Android, iOS) is one of the best dating apps in Toledo for Christian singles

Christian Mingle iOS

Believe it or not, over 44% of people in Toledo are religious and report themselves as following some form of Christian faith. This is why Christian Mingle is the perfect dating site for Christian singles in Toledo!

As you may have guessed from the name, everyone on the site is Christian, which already gives you something in common from the start.

For those who are ready to settle down or just avoid some of the “meat markets” that other apps seem to offer, Christian Mingle makes the dating process simple when looking for someone committed to their faith and, is looking for, a real-life partner.

Best of all, it’s free to try Christian Mingle to test the waters. With over 15+ million active users (and growing daily), you’re certain to find a partner in Toledo that shares your Christian beliefs to create a happy life together.

Why Christian Mingle is a great site for finding a like-minded partner

  • Easier to find like-minded people with similar values than in other less-specific apps
  • Available on desktop and as a smartphone app
  • Plenty of free features to try before deciding on a paid membership for even better results

What can be off-putting about Christian Mingle

  • Other dating sites may be better for you if you’re not a practicing Christian
  • Limited dating pool when compared to other apps
  • Not the best UX/UI design



#3 - AFF is the best dating site in Toledo for no-strings-attached fun (try it free here)


AFF is the best option when it comes to finding sexy fun in Toledo. From your laptop to your lap, matching results in Toledo is simple and straightforward - everyone’s here to hook up and have NSA fun, so there’s no pressure or awkwardness that you’ll find on other dating apps!

With 60+ million users, you won’t struggle to find someone DTF in Toledo with AFF. The site’s profiles go beyond the guesswork that comes with some of the other “hookup” apps, like Tinder. Users can filter profile searches based on a number of factors: distance/location, age, sexual preferences, body type, and much more to find the right match.

Best of all, AFF features a free trial to give you a taste of how it works, but most users want to dive right in with the relatively cheap membership fee and get the party started.

Why AFF is great for Toledo hookups

  • A large number of active users
  • Easy-to-use interface
  • Plenty of searches, broad profiles, interactions, and digital sex choices
  • Webcam options for those that want to set expectations well-before meeting in-person

What we don’t like about AFF

  • Can be a bit of a meat market
  • There’s a lot of competition for highly-desirable partners
You Can Try AFF Free!
If you're just looking for more short-term fun you need to try out AFF's free trial. We've spent months and months testing out the alternatives (more than 100 other sites) and haven't found anything that gives most guys more options and better results. Give it a shot!


#4 - Tinder (Android, iOS) is the best way for attractive singles to get together in Toledo

Tinder iOS screenshots

Tinder is the most popular dating app in the world - and it’s one of the most popular dating apps in Toledo bar-none.

Tinder makes it easy to get started to find singles in Toledo and beyond for hookups, long-term relationships, and other sexy pairings. Simply swipe left to weed out bad matches, swipe right to wait for a match, tap below to learn more about their profile (if you’re into that sort of thing), and start matching to begin the conversation.

But let’s be honest: Tinder’s reliance on photos means this is an app for attractive people. Tinder’s algorithm will try to pair you with women that are more in line with your looks and common interests. Best-suited for smartphones, Tinder is available for desktops too.

Why Tinder is great for Toledo singles

  • Largest pool of potential romantic partners and hookups in the Toledo area
  • Easy to use platform that takes seconds to start matching
  • Simple to get started with photos you have on your phone, Facebook profile, or even short videos

What can be off-putting about Tinder

  • Lots of competition
  • Hard to screen out scammers
  • A paid membership is expensive
  • It can be hard to make meaningful connections with so many options at hand



#5 - Bumble (Android, iOS) is the best app for women seeking men in Toledo

Bumble app features

Bumble is a unique app perfectly suited for Toledo’s large female population. Usually, men have to do all the work with apps like Tinder and play a “numbers” game, hitting up every profile they can in hopes that a woman might say “Hey” in response.

Bumble puts the onus on the woman to respond. Any time both of you swipe right on one another’s profiles, a 24-period countdown starts, giving only a short period for a woman to respond. This motivates her to reach out before you’re gone forever. Talk about FOMO!

By making it so women must message men first, Bumble enables women to match with anyone they think they’d be interested in, only to match with men that are actually interested in them to even the playing field!

Why Bumble is great for dating in Toledo

  • Less pressure for women with better results
  • Better quality  matches
  • Great free profile perks and paid membership features

What we don’t like about Bumble

  • Waiting on messages slows down the spontaneity for spontaneous hookups
  • Filling out your entire profile can take a lot of time and may seem redundant
  • You may struggle to stand out if you aren’t reasonably attractive or have interesting pictures



The Best Hookup Sites in Toledo

A couple about to hook up

If you’re not interested in a long-term relationship in Toledo right now, there are plenty of dating apps to help you find a casual partner. Here are some of the best Toledo hookup sites for you to try:

Cut out the nonsense with AFF

Adult Friend Finder is one of the best casual dating sites in Toledo, making it a cinch to cut our timewasters with a paid membership. Everyone who uses AFF is looking to have a good time without strings attached, but you’ll find better matches that actually pay to get their freak on. Give it a try and you might just find someone who’s as adventurous (or vanilla) as you are!

Plenty of Fish, plenty of success

Plenty of Fish (PoF) may not have the same user base as Tinder, but it certainly has fewer scammers and more users that only use PoF and nothing else. The paid PoF membership boosts the regular functionality of the app, making it MUCH easier to meet more available women and find a partner.

Pro tip: Sort users who are online now by their “Last Visit”. You’re more likely to get a response from someone who is actively using the PoF app.

The Best Dating Sites in Toledo for Serious Relationships

A couple showing off their rings

Let’s take a look at why eHarmony and Plenty of Fish are the best dating sites/apps in Toledo for finding relationships.

Why does eHarmony just make sense?

Considering Toledo has a large demographic that’s within the dating range (18 - 45), eHarmony is a natural choice for finding a partner no matter what age you’re looking for. With an emphasis on quality matches, eHarmony is one of the best dating apps in Toledo that actually works. Best of all, while eHarmony isn’t necessarily free, you can get a taste of who’s available by taking advantage of the free trial.

Zoosk is the relationship dating app for younger singles

eHarmony is great and all, but most users there are looking to settle down and get serious. But what about the younger singles who aren’t into hookups but are also not trying to dive headfirst into marriage? That’s where Zoosk comes in. It’s one of the more popular dating apps for singles 18-23 who want a pretty serious relationship.

The Best Free Dating Apps in Toledo

Woman checking out free dating apps while walking

Listen, modern dating is hard. And dating apps are meant to make it easier. There are plenty of good things about dating apps in Toledo, like accessing a wider group of women in your area. However, there are plenty of cons, such as expensive membership fees that simply don’t get results.

That being said, you’re likely to get better results if you pay for using an app - it’s their business model, after all. Think of it like paying a cover fee at a hot nightclub for access to better women versus just hitting up a trashy dive bar that’s too crowded. You’re essentially paying for better access, and finding love and/or hookups is a bargain for just about any popular dating app.

We’ve covered a bunch of free dating apps in Toledo. In addition to those mentioned, here are a few more free dating apps that can help you get the love you want:

  • Hinge
  • Coffee Meets Bagel
  • Hily

Best of luck!

Join Our Newsletter

No Spam. Just Higher Dating Success.

Leave a Comment