Our 12 Proven Spots to Find Sexy Single Cougars in Indiana for 2023

Gorgeous cougars in Indiana can be found in any city

When you’re out and about, it’s unavoidable that you’ll notice sexy cougars in Indiana occasionally passing by you, whether on the streets, out in the open or inside a bar.

If mature women are your type, then by now, you probably know a thing or two about them. For example, many Indiana cougars love shopping and going out, which is why you’ll spot them in places like Downtown Indianapolis or Clay Terrace. Because they take good care of their appearance, they’re also often health-conscious, and they’re loyal customers of organic stores like Good Earth.

Still, for a younger guy like you, it can be challenging to be at the right setting so you can approach them. After all, where do cougars in Indiana go to find cute guys they can date? Most dating scene recommendations will point you to the loudest bars. But results can be mixed. More often than not, these famous bars have more college kids who are too young for your taste.

To start dating cougars in Indiana, you need to know exactly where to start. Lucky for you, we've put together a list of our recommendations so you can save yourself the hassle of honing in on the wrong places with the wrong people.

Kick-off your cougar hunt at any of the Indiana cougar bars and destinations below. We’re excited to hear about your experiences, so feel free to leave a comment!

Our Preferred Locations to Find Cougars in Indiana

Out of the six million people in Indiana, there’s an amazing cougar waiting for you. Read on for our choices of places where you can find sexy older women in Indiana.

Explore the Indianapolis Museum of Art with a cultured cougar

Men and women mingling at the Indianapolis Museum of Art


If you’re into arts and culture and you’re after a cougar who can match your interests, then you might want to hang out regularly at the Indianapolis Museum of Art. Located inside the stunning Newsfields campus, it’s one of the oldest and largest museums in the country.

You’re guaranteed to love it here because whatever your taste in art, there’s a matching exhibit for you. There are more than 500,000 artworks here, including Asian, African and American art. Entry is usually $18, and with so much to explore, it’s worth it.

After all, you won’t just be walking around indoors. You have access to 152 acres worth of grounds, including interactive spaces, a charming garden and even a house that looks Gatsby-inspired.

Art aficionados can easily spend a whole day here. Striking up a conversation is a breeze too! Just look for any Indiana cougars admiring the artwork and tell her what you think about it. Chances are, you’ll eventually hit it off with someone, and you can stroll through the grounds with her for the rest of the day!

For something short-term you can’t beat AFF in our state

Homepage for AFF

While eHarmony is the ideal site for meeting cougars who want a serious relationship, it’s not at all effective for meeting older women who are looking for flings. For that, you’ll need to use another site that’s just as reliable. Our top pick for meeting cougars who want some quick, naughty fun is AFF.

Nothing beats AFF at helping you find a feisty cougar who wants to hop into bed with you. It’s been around for years and it remains one of the best sites out there for meeting people for some sexy fun. Literally everyone who is on AFF is looking to get laid. So you won’t have to worry too much about mentioning where and when you can meet up to get it on.

AFF is full of cougars who are on the prowl. Tweak the age search filter and you’ll meet hundreds of them in your city. Indiana is full of horny, naughty older ladies and so many of them love using AFF!

Try AFF For Free!
If you actually want to meet single cougars who are more interested in fun in the bedroom than a long-term relationship you need to check out AFF's free trial with this link. We've spent many months testing out 100+ different sites and apps to meet cougars and AFF has consistently been the easiest way for most men.


Get fit and impress Indiana cougars at Life Time

Cougars in Indiana at a spin class in Life Time


Life Time at North Meridian is hands down the best gym all over the state, which is why it attracts tons of fit and gorgeous Indiana cougars. This luxury fitness center has made a name for itself all over the US. When you try the North Meridian branch, you’ll want to sign up for a long membership! We know how to find a cougar locally whose single and ready to mingle. You'll love this spot.

For one, facilities are always clean and spotless, and you have access to endless equipment. You can use cardio and weight machines, benches, free weights and more. There’s even a basketball court and swimming pool, and you can unwind afterwards at the hot tub or sauna.

The best part is it’s so big that you rarely have to line up for your turn with the equipment! Aside from improving your fitness, just going here will put you in the vicinity of hot older women who are looking for a catch.

To flirt with plenty of cougars, you can go a step further and join certain classes. Zumba and yoga are popular among older women, and you might find your future cougar date there.

eHarmony is the top site if you want a relationship with an Indiana cougar (try it here)

Homepage for EHQuick flings, one night stands and casual relationships are so common these days. But if you’re the type of guy who’s looking for the real deal, dating will only give you a headache! After all, what’s the point of meeting so many beautiful older women when all they want is a night of fun before calling it quits? To be fair, not all women want something quick and easy. There are plenty of mature ladies who want something more long-lasting. And the best place to find these ladies is on eHarmony.

After trying out all the top sites out there for meeting cougars we can confidently say that most guys are going to get the best results here, especially if they're looking for a relationship.

eHarmony isn’t your average site for meeting singles. It’s one that has a thorough process that may be a little time-consuming, but we promise it’s worth it. You see, when you create an account on eHarmony, you’ll need to fill up a survey about who you’re interested in and who you are as a person. Through this information, eHarmony helps you find some matches in their gigantic userbase. So if you only want to date women who are at least 10 years older than you, eHarmony does its best to find ladies who’ll match your personality and interests.

On top of this, the majority of the women who use eHarmony are looking for a relationship. So if you’re done playing the dating game, this is the site you need to try.

75% of all marriages in the United States that started online started on eHarmony. No other site boasts stats like that!

eHarmony will always be our go-to site for finding worthwhile dates with women who aren’t here to just fool around. Because of how effective the site is, we always put it in our list of the best sites for meeting cougars. But don’t take our word for it. Try eHarmony's proven trial out today and it might just change your dating life!

eHarmony trial

Indulge in decadent wine tasting at Cooper’s Hawk Winery and Restaurants

Wine and appetizers from Cooper's Hawk Winery


Cooper’s Hawk Winery is an absolute cougar den. Dress well and look your best because you’ll be seeing plenty of fashionable, well-off Indiana cougars here. Usually in their 40s and 50s, these cougars walk confidently in heels and know their wine.

Offering both upscale dining and wine tasting, Cooper’s has already gained many loyal customers. Whether at the bar or main restaurant area, expect it to be crowded here, even during noon on weekdays.

Their specialty here is wine. You can avail of the rotating wine tasting menu, which is more fun to try with a cougar by your side! To maximize your chances of sweeping a cougar off her feet, try joining the wine club. This will give you access to special events with other wine lovers (and more hot cougars).

On the other hand, the decadent menu features various cuisines, including Italian, Asian and even steaks. Our go-to when dining here is the Soy Ginger Salmon. Portions can be quite large, so if you’ve snagged the attention of a cougar, the two of you can share for a more romantic dinner.

Spend your Saturday night with Indiana cougars at Daddy Jack’s

An appetizer and beer from Kona Jack's


On Saturday nights, this place becomes a favorite hunting ground for cougars in Indiana. While the cocktails and the atmosphere alone are already great selling points, Saturday nights are the best time to visit because of the live bands and overall thrilling scene.

The dress code is casual. Even with live music, it never gets too loud in there. It’s the perfect setting for having an intimate conversation or a private people-watching session with a sexy older woman. So if you're in Indianapolis on a Saturday night and aren't sure where to go, make sure your plans include a stop at Daddy Jacks. You won’t regret it!

The Apps Dating Coaches Recommend Most To Meet Cougars

More and more older women are only using apps and sites to meet guys, especially younger guys. You need to be on at least one or two apps now if you want to get the best results you can. These are the apps that give normal guys the best success meeting cougars:

SiteOur ExperienceOur RatingFree Trial Link
Best Hookup Site Cougars
Experience Highlights
Experience Highlights
  • The best way to meet cougars for hookups by far
  • Best results for regular guys
  • Over 60 million active members
  • Not good for long-term relationships
Try AFF For Free
Best For Relationships
Experience Highlights
Experience Highlights
  • Easily the best option for long-term relationships
  • 75% of all online marriages start here
  • 70% of users meet their spouse within a year
  • In-depth signup and matching process
Try eHarmony
2nd Best For Hookups
Experience Highlights
Experience Highlights
  • 2nd best option to find hookups
  • Attracts an older crowd than most hookup apps
  • Pretty popular
  • Great free trial
Try Passion

Enjoy comfort food and great drinks at Flatwater Restaurant

A crowd enjoying the music in the crowd of Flatwater Restaurant


Located in Indianapolis' Broad Ripple section, this place is not only an awesome choice for a meal but a great place to find cougars in Indiana. In turn, Flatwater is well-known among cougars as a venue for meeting younger guys interested in older women.

The best night to stop by is Saturday (perhaps before you head to Daddy Jack’s) because that's when the cougars are on the prowl. And if you're not hungry, they also have a full bar and a back porch that's perfect for mingling with the pretty patrons.

Unleash your desire for sexy cougars at Liberty Street

Friends on a fun night out at Liberty Street Bar


If you're a fan of intricately-made cocktails and craft beers, this is the place for you. The quiet atmosphere is perfect for a more in-depth and intimate conversation. There's outdoor seating if you feel like looking over the surroundings. But we think you'll have more than enough to look at from inside the bar.

The best nights to go are Tuesday and Saturday. But you're guaranteed to find a bevy of cougars looking for younger guys.

Course promo

Live music acts always draw the Indiana cougars to Lamasco Bar and Grill

Various dishes from Lamasco Bar and Grill


This down-to-earth downtown bar in Evansville comes alive every weekend thanks to its multiple music acts. Whether you're a fan of country, bluegrass, rock or alternative, Lamasco always bring in some talented bands. The great thing about this is that music is the universal unifier. Find out the schedule for one of your favorite bands and you just might meet a cougar who's into the same music as you. Find her in the audience, offer to buy her a beer and who knows where the night will lead!

With awesome music, fantastic pub grub and cheap drinks, there's no way you won't have a fun night out at Lamasco!

Cardinal Spirits in Bloomington is a famous Indiana cougar bar

The beautiful bartender mixing drinks at Cardinal Spirits


Feel like grabbing a drink at a classy establishment that's full of sexy older women? Cardinal Spirits is where you should go! This stylish boutique and distillery offers a wide range of cocktails, some of which are made to order. So if you're looking to impress a cougar you just met at the bar, asking the bartender for some specials might be the way to her heart. And if she's not the cocktail type, then Cardinal Spirits' selection of brews will definitely impress her!

Single woman

Visit the Bloomington Community Farmers’ Market for cougar connections

Fresh produce from Bloomington Farmers Market


The unexpected nature of chatting up a sexy older woman while she's shopping for produce might yield better results than you'd think. If you're looking to kill two birds with one stone, the Bloomington Community Farmers' Market is a great option.

There's something to be said for places that aren't considered "traditional" options for meeting cougars. And this farmers' market is no different. Best of all, with so many things to do at the farmers' market, if you do meet a sexy older woman, you can have a nice walk-and-talk while you get to know one another.

The Bloomington Community Farmers' Market runs from April through November, so be aware of that before you head over. And even if you strike out, you can still do some grocery shopping while you're there.

For more guides to meeting single cougars check these out:

Meet cougars in Illinois - Meet cougars in Iowa

Join Our Newsletter

No Spam. Just Higher Dating Success.

Leave a Comment