When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

9 Awesome Places To Find Hot Indianapolis Casual Encounters in 2024

Artsy guy finding Indianapolis casual encounters at a beer garden

Running low on your luck while trying to score some hot Indianapolis casual encounters? Well, don’t give up hope just yet. Coming across the right spots for meeting a one night stand takes a bit of experience. That’s why we’ve crafted the ultimate guide for meeting the sexiest women for casual encounters in Indianapolis.

With our guidance, you’ll stop wasting time at all the wrong bars and sites and instead hit up the best spots. For example, you may have assumed that O’Reilly’s Irish Bar or Broad Ripple Tavern are both solid options. However, you could wind up wasting hours there with no options in sight. The drive back home on I-465 will be a lonely one. To help you avoid wasting time and money, we’ve compiled a list of the bars, clubs and websites that have gotten us lucky every time.

If you’re looking for a hot one-time fling, then check out our recommendations!

Where Indianapolis Casual Encounters Actually Happen

Here are our favorite bars and websites that have successfully gotten us lucky in finding casual encounters in Indianapolis:

Casba is a popular dance bar for finding Indianapolis casual encounters


Casba is a great place to dance

If you enjoy the idea of dancing the night away, then hit up Casba. This awesome nightclub hosts some of the best DJs in the area. Located in the basement of Broad Ripple, this place is the epitome of a basement party. The music is always different and you can expect a great mixture of reggae, salsa, dancehall and hip-hop.

However, our favorite thing about this nightclub is the women who show up. Women of all ages and backgrounds come here to dance the night away. Even if you’re a bit shy, the small quarters of the club make it easy for you to make the first move. You’ll be dumbfounded by the sheer number of women coming here to unwind for a girls night, all while looking for someone to spend the night with.

AFF is the easiest way to find casual encounters in Indianapolis (try it free)

If you’d much rather look for a casual relationship from the comfort of your home, then try out AFF. With a user base of over 90 million, the odds of you meeting someone you’re actually interested in are high. The site works great for men of all ages and you don’t have to be particularly handsome to get good results.

The site has been around for years and has acquired quite a reputation as well. Unlike other apps like Tinder, AFF focuses on bringing people together around physical relationships. There are no strings attached among the users on AFF. We know because we’ve used the site for ourselves over the years!

Along with its great reputation, the site also has real users. You won’t have to worry about running into fake bot profiles or catfish accounts. While using the site we have yet to come across a fake profile.

AFF does the best job of actually helping guys find casual encounters out of all the options out there!

However, if all of this hasn’t won you over yet then you may change your mind when we unveil the best part. AFF allows you to filter through users based on your own preferences. Some of the filters include age, distance, kink and more. You’ll come across an endless number of possible one-night encounters on AFF alone.

Try AFF For Free!
Using this link to AFF's free trial offer you can check out exactly why so many guys have had success using it. It really is the best option for most guys that we've found.


Beers and Indianapolis casual encounters come easy at Rathskeller


The Rathskeller is great for mingling and listening to live tunes

The Rathskeller is one of our favorite places for great beers and even greater conversation. It’s perfect if you’re interested in a mixed environment. There are areas where you can listen to amazing live music blasting and other areas perfect for just kicking back and talking. Either way, you’ll have the perfect opportunity to find Indianapolis casual encounters. We recommend heading here between Wednesday and Saturday nights to catch a live performance.

The beerhall has both outdoor and indoor seating as well. So if you happen to head out on a particularly warm night you can enjoy the view of the night sky. The food here is great too, so don’t skip out! You’ll find that introducing yourself to women comes easy here. Everyone is cool, laidback and sexy. You won’t find a better beerhall atmosphere in the area.


Homepages for Alt.com

When you want BDSM casual encounters in Indianapolis use Alt.com (try it free)

If you’re craving a kinkier sex experience, then you should give Alt.com a try. Finding women in person who are into BDSM encounters is almost impossible. Just the sheer mention of the word could have a gorgeous woman running for the hills. Alt.com makes it possible to satisfy all of your fantasies. The site is one of the largest completely dedicated to helping people interested in BDSM, kinks and fetishes find each other.

The site has been around for a while and has managed to build up a great community. The women on the site are incredibly welcoming and inviting, especially to new users. It’s also incredibly easy to use. Since the site has a great reputation, you also won’t have to worry about being catfished either. We haven’t run into bots or fake profiles while searching for Indianapolis casual encounters on Alt.com.

However, the best part about the site is how it caters to niche fetishes. Since there’s already a relatively small number of people in each city interested in these kinds of encounters, you need a tool that will help connect you. What we love about Alt.com is that you don’t have to go around admitting your sexual preferences in person either. This helps you keep things more private without alienating you from the community.

So if you have a niche kink that you’re dying to fulfill, give Alt.com a try!


The Brass Ring Lounge is a small spot with awesome vibes

The Brass Ring Lounge is one of our favorite late-night spots. The food options are great with pizza, tacos and more to choose from. However, what really won us over is the speakeasy vibe. The place is small and intimate. Interesting women flock here with one thing in mind. The outdoor patio is a great spot to bring your drink and strike up a conversation with some ladies.

Some of our hottest Indianapolis casual encounters have happened during a late-night last-minute drop-in here. Order one of their cocktails and don’t be surprised by how strong they make them. Everything is also reasonably priced as well, so you won’t go broke having a drink here.

Craiglist was one of the most popular options for coming across one night stands. The personals message boards were full of anonymous users looking for no-strings-attached fun. Users would post exactly what they were looking for and they would sometimes include photos of themselves as well.

Although the message boards were easy to navigate, they don't offer the highest-quality one-nighters. These days, the Indianapolis Craigslist casual encounters personals board is gone. However, it’s not too much of a loss as the anonymity led to tons of catfish situations. While you might still come across a few personal ads sprinkled throughout the site, they’re not worth going through.


The intimate atmosphere of The Ball and Biscuit make it perfect for finding casual encounters in Indianapolis


Enjoy creative cocktails at Ball & Biscuit

Ball & Biscuit is an awesome place to go to if you’re interested in more of an artsy scene. The place offers up some amazing cocktails that are different from ones you’ll find anywhere else. This is the quintessential bar where women head to enjoy unique cocktails with their gal pals. The odds of you finding hot Indianapolis casual encounters here are really high!

The low lighting of the bar keeps is romantic and perfect for flirting. Tons of young professionals often come here too. So if you want a conversation with an intelligent woman and then take that spark to the bedroom, this is the place to do it.

The Apps Dating Experts Recommend To Regular Guys In Indianapolis

If you're not using at least one of these apps you're going to struggle to find anything casual around town. Post-Covid, almost all of these connections are happening online first. If you're not giving these a shot you're missing out. They are where most guys have the best results:

SiteOur ExperienceOur RatingFree Trial Link
Best Casual Encounter Site
Experience Highlights
Experience Highlights
  • Top option for local hookups by far
  • Best results for regular guys
  • Over 60 million active members
  • The design needs an update
Try AFF For Free
Great If You're Handsome
Tinder Highlights
Tinder Highlights
  • Great if you're pretty good looking
  • Very popular, especially if you're 18-22
  • Really focused on photos
  • Becoming more of a dating than hookup app
Try Tinder
2nd Best For Most Guys
Experience Highlights
Experience Highlights
  • 2nd best option to find hookups for most
  • Attracts an older crowd than most hookup apps
  • Pretty popular
  • Solid free trial
Try Passion

Locanto in Indianapolis is quickly gaining relevance

Indianapolis Locanto has quickly swooped us in as an alternative to Craigslist. When the Craigslist personal ads vanished, Locanto has become the new go-to. On Locanto, you can find tons of personal ads from users looking for a quick fling. While the site is free to use and easy to navigate, it doesn't exactly have the highest quality options.

Since the users are anonymous, you have no way of verifying who you’re talking to. You could wind up making plans with a fake account or a catfish. No one wants their time wasted and that’s why we typically avoid Locanto in Indianapolis. There are far better options for coming across Indianapolis casual encounters. Any of the other sites we mentioned would give you far better results.

Dorman Street is our favorite place to just grab a beer, kick back and relax. The women who come here are super cool and not uptight. Since the bar has more of a neighborhood vibe everyone is friendly and most people know each other. You can easily strike up a conversation without looking like a creep.

The drinks are super affordable and the beer on tap is great. There’s a pool table as well, so you can actually have fun while drinking. There are also TVs throughout the bar broadcasting the latest sports game. You’ll be sure to have fun at this spot.

Join Our Newsletter

No Spam. Just Higher Dating Success.

Leave a Comment