The Best Indianapolis Dating Apps & Sites to Try this 2022

Woman in her office looking for the best dating apps in Indianapolis

When it comes to finding a partner, people always say there’s plenty of fish in the sea. This is especially true in the most populated city of Indiana, Indianapolis. But how do you go about finding the perfect fish? Dating apps! Dating apps are becoming increasingly more popular, with many people finding lasting relationships on them. But which ones truly stand out as the best dating apps in Indianapolis?

Our team of experts has tried out over 150 dating apps to find the best ones for you, Indianapolis. Without further ado, here are the eight best dating apps for residents of Brendonwood, Fountain Square, Broad Ripple or any neighborhood in the city.


Ship app screenshot

#1 - Ship is one of the best dating apps in Indianapolis for singles who value their friends’ opinion (Android; iOS)

Ship creates a new way to date. Finding the perfect match for yourself can be tough, especially when there are so many people to choose from. Ship takes the choice out of your hand and puts it into your friends’ hands. On the app, you create your profile like any other dating app. Then, invite your crew to sign up as matchmakers, and they can do all the swiping and matching for you.

Ship is a great way to get all of your friends’ opinions in real-time as well. That’s because you can all video chat and swipe through your potential matches together.

Why Ship is a great dating app

  • Great way to date and spend time with your friends
  • You can also use Ship by yourself if you want to
  • Group video chat is a great way to get immediate opinions

What we don’t like about it

  • Ship is still quite new, so the dating pool is small
  • You only have a limited amount of “likes” per day



eHarmony screenshots

#2 - eHarmony (Android; iOS) is the best Indianapolis dating apps for real relationships

eHarmony is super popular in Indianapolis and we've all seen their commercials. You also probably know several couples that met using their app, even if they won't admit it to you! Out of all the apps we've tried nothing really compares to the popularity and success rates that eHarmony has had.

Let's talk numbers, 75% of all marriages that have started online happened because of eHarmony. 75%! That's a crazy high number. When you consider that there are several other really big apps out there that number is even crazier. This is an app that really works.

What we really like about eHarmony is that it actually does a lot of the work for you. It finds out what you want, matches you with people that fit your criteria that are looking for singles like you, and then helps you get to know each other. It's a much better experience than the other meat markets out there which don't do anything to help.

Check out their trial offer below and see just how good it is!

eHarmony trial

Why eHarmony has a great reputation

  • Really popular in Indianapolis and really successful
  • Daily curated matches are sent to you
  • By far the best success rates of any app out there right now

What we don't like about it

  • The sign-up process is longer than most
  • You can’t search for matches on your own



Silver Singles app screenshots

#3 - Silver Singles is one of the best dating sites in Indianapolis for older people (Android; iOS)

Silver Singles is one of the top sites to find love as an older person. Dating in general when you’re older can be tough as many people are married or just coming out of marriages. With the inception of Silver Singles, however, dating as an older person is simple.

Silver Singles is perfect for people over 50. The app uses the psychological test to discover more about your personality and what is important to you when it comes to dating. Based on your results, users will receive curated matches daily.

Why Silver Singles is one of the best Indianapolis dating apps

  • People over 50 can comfortably date people their age
  • Matches are based on compatibility rather than looks
  • Silver Singles values privacy and safety

What we don’t like about it

  • The free version is limited
  • Signing up can take some time as you have to answer an in-depth quiz



AFF dating site screenshots

#4 - AFF is the best hookup app in Indianapolis right now

AFF is the best Indianapolis hookup app right now in our experience. It has a ton of users, everyone is looking for the same thing, and they make it easy to communicate. It's also the best option by far for single guys that we've tried and consistently works a LOT better than Tinder.

Tinder is the main competition here but it's turning into more of a dating app these days with a focus on relationships. AFF is still completely focused on being the best hookup app in town. When you combine a lot of users and a single focus you get a pretty good app.

If you haven't had much luck on Tinder or just want to avoid all the attention seekers who never want to meet this is going to be a different experience. Check out their free trial below and see for yourself.

Why AFF is one of the best dating sites in Indianapolis

  • Lots of users in Indianapolis and very popular across the country
  • Where single guys have had the best success, by far
  • A single focus that makes it easy to save a ton of time

What we don’t like about it

  • Many users can only access via web app
  • Not a fan of the ads
  • Design needs improvement
You Can Try AFF Free!
If you're just looking for a fling or more short-term fun you need to try out AFF's free trial. We've spent months and months testing out the alternatives (more than 100 other sites) and haven't found anything that gives most guys more options and better results. Give it a shot!


Bumble app screenshots

#5 - Bumble is one of the top apps for women who like to lead (Android; iOS)

Bumble is for women who want to be in control of their dating life. Many women stay away from online dating because they receive unwanted messages that can sometimes border on harassment. On Bumble, the woman must message the man first within 24 hours or the match disappears. This helps limit unwanted interactions and helps women decide the terms of their interactions.

Why Bumble is one of the best dating apps in Indianapolis for women

  • Bumble is extremely popular among the young crowd (20 to 35 years old)
  • With over 100 million users on Bumble, the dating pool is huge
  • Women have total control of who messages them

What we don’t like about it

  • 70% of users are under 35 so it’s not a great app for an older crowd
  • There may be a learning curve for women who are not used to making the first move



Hinge app screenshots

#6 - Hinge is great for getting the conversation started (Android; iOS)

Hinge seamlessly emphasizes the importance of finding people you are both attracted to and compatible with. Many people complain that dating apps like Tinder are too appearance-based, so Hinge lets users create detailed profiles. If you want to match with someone, you need to like or comment on a specific aspect of a person’s profile. This helps slow your endless scrolling down so you can actually get to know someone.

Hinge is quite popular with over 6 million active users a month, making it one of the best dating apps in Indianapolis. The free version is easily usable but you are limited to ten likes a day.

Why Hinge is one of our favorite dating apps

  • Profiles are detailed and have conversation starters to make sending the first message easier
  • Users get a daily match recommendation
  • The app is user friendly and setting up your profile is free

What we don’t like about it

  • The free version only offers 10 likes a day
  • No one has to send the first message as you can simply invite your match to start the conversation



Pickable app screenshots

#7 - Pickable is a solid app for passive dating (Android; iOS)

Pickable is the perfect app for men who are tired of spending all their time swiping through profiles. On most dating apps, men outnumber women. This leaves men with fewer options of profiles to look at. On Pickable, however, men can’t look at a women’s profile at all.

Women can remain anonymous and look through profiles of men that have set themselves as “pickable”. Then, women can reach out to the man of their choice if they’re interested to start a chat. We say it’s one of the best Indianaplis dating apps if you’re tired of swiping all day!

Why you should try Pickable

  • Women can remain anonymous, so connections aren’t shallow
  • Men can sit back and relax instead of spending time swiping
  • Signup is easy and free

What we don’t like about it

  • Men don’t have to do anything other than upload one picture
  • There are no filtering mechanisms to narrow down your search



The league app screenshots

#8 - The League is one of the best apps in Indianapolis for the elite crowd (Android; iOS)

The League is one of the best dating apps in Indianapolis if you’re rich. It’s where the elite crowd can date comfortably without worrying they’re being taken advantage of. There is a rigorous approval process where users need to send in their Facebook and Linkedin profiles along with six photos. The League team will then decide whether or not you would be a good fit for the app.

Thanks to the extensive investigation, everyone is verified so catfishing is impossible. The free version of The League is good, but a paid membership gets you more benefits like expediting your time on the waitlist.

Why The League is one of the best dating sites in Indianapolis

  • Everyone on the app is verified
  • The matching process is more thoughtful as you only receive three potential matches a day
  • Every user has access to a concierge who can offer help with optimizing your profile

What we don’t like about it

  • Signing up is difficult as you must send in a lot of information
  • The League doesn’t have set guidelines on what you can do to get approved



Dine screenshots

#9 - Dine Dating is a great dating app for foodies (Android; iOS)

Dine Dating is the best way to try new restaurants and bars with your date. When you sign up, you get to choose your three favorite bars or restaurants in Indianapolis. After matching, you and your date can pick a meeting place from both of your choices. This helps take away any back and forth about where you should meet.

Men need the premium version of Dine Dating to message other users, though. As Dine Dating sends you daily matches, meeting up with people is easy.

Why Dine Dating is worth downloading

  • You will get to discover new restaurants and bars in Indianapolis
  • Dine Dating offers recommendations to help improve your profile
  • You will receive daily matches from Dine Dating

What we don’t like about it

  • Men need the premium plan to message women
  • A Facebook account is necessary for sign up


Join Our Newsletter

No Spam. Just Higher Dating Success.

Leave a Comment