2020's Top 11 Indianapolis Dating Apps To Meet Someone Special

Indianapolis Indiana blonde using apps to datePicking the best Indianapolis dating apps isn’t all that easy anymore. There are so many different dating apps to choose from, which make things a little more complicated. Luckily, after having personally tested out all of the best dating apps in the market from Carmel to Pogue’s Run, we have carefully selected the top options for everybody. You’re welcome.

Below, we will help you find the best dating app to meet your personal needs and desires. The good news for everybody is that Indianapolis is full of attractive singles just waiting for you on the right platform. This isn’t some small, middle-of-nowhere town like Logansport, after all. College students attending one of our fine institutions like Butler and Purdue are especially prime for getting some attention.

In order to help everybody, we are going to break down the best dating apps in Indianapolis for different preferences. Some people use dating apps to find a hookup, others use them to find a long-term relationship based on deep levels of compatibility. In reality, people of all levels of attractiveness, age and intentions can have lots of success if they simply use the right platform.

Below, we will go through the many top Indianapolis dating apps that we have personally seen work. We want to help you find the right platform. Since about 33% of the 863,000 people living in Indianapolis are single, there are plenty of options for you just waiting to be discovered.

Our Favorite Indianapolis Dating Apps

As we mentioned, the best dating apps in Indianapolis can be a little subjective, depending on what you are looking for and who you are. In order to best serve everybody, we will break down our top options into particular categories which meet the needs of the diverse audience of people who enjoy using dating apps.

Mature women on the prowl and their male admirers need to check out Cougar Life

Cougar Life is the best dating app to meet women over 35

Indianapolis has some of the finest older women looking for single men. This type of relationship is very common and it’s natural (and fun) to experience it at least once in your life. Due to the large abundance of older women ready to purr all over you, Cougar Life is consistently ranked in our list of favorite cougar dating apps and apps. They have been the best in Indianapolis for years now.

If you have ever taken a stroll through the local scene in Carmel, you should be well aware of the many attractive older women that Indianapolis has to offer. If you are an older woman wanting to try out some younger meat, or a younger male looking for a beautiful older kitty, make sure to try a free trial on Cougar Life.

We have put together another list of our favorite ways to meet Indianapolis cougars if you want a few more suggestions.

Try Cougar Life For Free


Most people in Indianapolis looking for a quick fling have the best luck on Adult FriendFinder

Homepage or Adult FriendFinder hookup appNot everyone is looking for a long-term relationship. With so much going on you might just be looking for some short-term fun with someone who isn't looking for any strings attached. If that is the case Adult FriendFinder is going to be what you are looking for. There are a lot of sketchy apps out there and they are one of the very few that actually delivers on their promise.

When it comes to finding casual fun around the city this is going to be the best app. It’s certainly the one that we have seen the best success with across a wide variety of people. Not only does it work well for those in their 20’s but it is unusually good for those who are 30+. Unlike Tinder, a lot of people who are a bit older are actually using it. If there is one app to try when you're single and looking for a dating app it’s this one.

They have over 90 million active members and have been the most popular app for short-term fun since they started in 2006. They are pretty popular in Indianapolis and really the best option unless you are a really good looking guy or pretty good looking woman interested in dating people under 30 (in which case Tinder is better).

For those of us who are not models or actually interested in hooking up with people out of their 20's Adult FriendFinder's free trial is where you should start. You can try them for free there really isn't any excuse NOT to give them a shot and see what we mean.

Try Adult FriendFinder For Free!
If you haven't tried it yet, you need to check out Adult Friend Finder's free trial offer with this link and see for yourself. We've tried out and ranked over 100 different sites and apps and most guys have done better here than anywhere else. There isn't an easier option out there.


Ambitious college-grads normally go straight to Elite Singles

Elite Singles is the best dating app to meet people with college degrees

Many people who want a relationship simply aren’t willing to start dating nobodies who work at McDonald's. To be fair, it’s completely normal to expect your partner to have a similar level of intelligence and education as you. This is why educated individuals love to use Elite Singles.

The reason Elite Singles is so popular is that there is a nice pairing algorithm for helping you find the career-focused person with a similar level of education and walk of life. Thanks to the presence of great institutions like Butler and Purdue in Indianapolis, around 31% of the city’s resident have a college education.

If you are tired of using mediocre dating apps that always pair you with a mooch looking for a sugar momma or sugar daddy, then you need to start seeking options in the right place. Having a partner who values their career as much as you do helps nurture a long-term relationship. Maybe they won't talk about it on WTHR, but this site is great.

Try Elite Singles For Free


Single parents in Indianapolis should try eHarmony

eHarmony is the best app for single parents

Being a single parent can be rough. If you aren’t enjoying being on your own, you don’t have to stay that way. There are over 12 million single-parent households in the USA. This means that a large chunk of them are found right here in Indianapolis.

Single parents tend to have a harder time finding relationships since many people are too shallow to consider dating somebody with a child. After all, it may already be hard enough to commit to one person. Let alone two.

What really stands out with eHarmony is that it has an advanced artificial intelligence algorithm to help you find people that know just about everything that there is to know about you. With such a nice pairing system, single parents have great luck here. It also is best for ensuring that the next person you bring home to your kids will be someone who sticks around.

This app has been especially good for the single guys who haven't yet found the best ways to meet an Indianapolis MILF. We've seen a lot of guys have great success here, with and without children themselves.

Try eHarmony Now


Attractive people in Indianapolis looking for hookups are on Tinder

Logo for Tinder appNot everybody is ready for a relationship. If you want the physical loving without the commitment, then Tinder can be one of your favorite ways to find an Indianapolis hookup. Just be warned, Tinder isn’t always the best place for men with average to below-average looks, especially if you don't know the best ways to start a conversation on Tinder.

A lot of the people on Tinder are attractive women. They also have options beyond options. This is why especially handsome men are the ones with the best luck on Tinder. Just keep in mind that rejection and flakiness is very common for people on both sides.

Good-looking folks wanting a hookup should go straight to Tinder for the best luck. It is possible to secure a relationship on Tinder, but unlikely. The best candidates for this application are women who need a nice ego-boost or an easy hookup. Even if you aren’t looking for a hookup, you can receive the assurance that you are gorgeous and desirable. For everyone else, look elsewhere (even the Dugout).

Try Tinder For Free


BBW women, and the men that value them, are on eHarmony

Being a BBW can be a little more difficult. There are lots of shallow men who expect your body to fit a specific standard. Thankfully, there are also many who don’t. In fact, many men prefer lovely BBWs to anyone else. They are easily found on eHarmony. This is the best dating app in Indianapolis for people who want a platform for full-figured beauties.

eHarmony does a fantastic job because they have a HUGE number of people using it. The site only matches you up with BBW who are looking for someone like you.

When you can use an extremely popular dating app that does all the work for you it's something special and is a big reason most guys have the best success with BBW using it. You need to check out their trial offer here.

Just because you are a little bit larger than other women doesn’t mean that men won’t give you a chance. This is why eHarmony has such a large audience. If you want to avoid all the shallow nonsense, this is the best platform for you to use. All types of intentions, from hookups to long-term relationships can be met here which easily makes it one of our recommended ways to meet BBW in Indianpolis.

Finding Christian singles in Indianapolis is best done on Christian Mingle

Being a Christian in today’s world can be exhausting. We live in a broken world full of sin, especially when it comes to adultery and not following Biblical law. That is why online dating can be a lot more difficult in Indianapolis as a Christian.

With many of the dating apps we have discussed above, you can easily be turned off by the attractive people who only end up wanting you in the bed. As you know, though, true Christians are a lot different. They want to get to know the person inside.

Christians usually seek long-term relationships. In the online dating world, though, these are a tad harder to find. If you want to meet someone who values their faith as much as you do, go straight to Christian Mingle. It’s an app that will help you make a spiritual connection as well as a physical one.

Finding singles over 50 in Indianapolis is best done using Our Time

Being an older person doesn’t mean that your dating career is over. While you are breathing, you are always able to find people around your age looking for a relationship. In fact, a considerably large number of people over 50 in Indianapolis are on Our Time.

Indianapolis is home to some of the most beautiful older people in the United States. For any number of reasons, not everybody is able to secure a long-term relationship that lasts their entire life. That’s where Our Time comes in.

You might be surprised how wonderful many of the people you can find on this website are. Best of all, the website is very easy to use, even for those who aren’t that tech-savvy.

The General Indianapolis Dating Apps To Consider

Now that we have gone through the apps for more specific tastes here are our favorites that don’t cater to a particular crowd:

If you are looking for more than a quick hookup check out eHarmony

When it comes to giving you the best chances of meeting single women seeking men in Indianapolis you are actually compatible with you can beat eHarmony in Indianapolis. Unlike the other major dating apps out there, eHarmony actually has a signup process that is more than throwing up a couple of photos and a lame joke or two.

A more intensive signup process allows for much better automatic matching and also filters out the people who are not even committed enough to spend 15-20 minutes to answer a few questions. If you are looking for more than a quick fix and want to save a lot of time and money, in the long run, you can’t beat them.

OKcupid and Plenty of Fish are also decent but have some downsides

No list of dating apps in Indianapolis would be complete without including OKC and POF. These are two sites that almost everyone has signed up on at one time or another.

Now, OKC and POF have a lot of users, which is great. The problem is that very few people on the site seem to actually put much effort into it. We have yet to find another app that has as little activity per subscriber.

You can definitely get results if you spend a lot of time but in our experience, it just wasn’t worth it. The same amount of time and effort spend on other apps yielded much better results.

If you are looking for more great guides to finding the right dating apps check these out:

Next - Previous

Join Our Newsletter For Exclusive Dating Tips & Advice
No Spam.
Just Higher Dating Success.

Leave a Comment