When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

The Best Spots for Indianapolis Hookups in 2023 (Our Favorites)

Single ladies eager for hookups in Indianapolis

If you live in the area and are wondering about the best places to find Indianapolis hookups, look no further my friend. We are going to share with you our favorite online options, as well as the best hookup bars singles love to use in Indy. It’s not that we think finding casual sex in this city is hard. We simply want you equipped with the best of the best in the hookup world of our city.

When we put our list, we did so with all of Indianapolis in mind. So whether you live in a ritzy neighborhood like Carmel, near urban Pogue’s Run or even in the small town of Logansport, we’ve got the ultimate list to help you get laid in Indianapolis! And no matter your age, as long as you are old enough to hook up, we have something for you.

Finding some fun in Indy has never been easier. Take a look below and see for yourself why these hookup sources are our favorites.

Our favorite spots to find Indianapolis hookups

Hookup bars and online hookup options go hand-in-hand. Use both and you double your chances of finding what you're looking for, day or night. To increase your chances of finding someone right now, check out these top recommendations.

Four Finger Distillery is Indianapolis' hidden gem for memorable hookups


Four Finger Distillery in Indianapolis was an unexpected delight and a fantastic addition to the city's vibrant hookup scene. Tucked away in the heart of Indianapolis, this distillery boasts a unique combination of craft spirits and a laid-back, inviting atmosphere. It's the kind of place where I could easily strike up conversations over meticulously crafted cocktails and explore the potential for memorable connections. I didn't even need to try too hard--the regulars here are just that easy to approach!

The charm of Four Finger Distillery lies in its intimate setting and diverse crowd. Whether you're sitting at the bar, indulging in their signature drinks, or enjoying one of their special events, there's a sense of camaraderie that makes mingling feel natural. My evening at Four Finger Distillery was filled with engaging conversations, laughter, and the promise of exciting encounters, making it a top recommendation for anyone seeking a fun and flirtatious night out in Indianapolis.

Newfields Beer Garden is one of the best bars to get laid

A group of singles at Newfields Beer Garden


If you love a good beer as much as we do then you must head over to Newfields. The beer garden at Newfields is the perfect place to scout for beautiful women. Nestled right next to the historic Madeline F. Elder Greenhouse, Newfields beer garden is very popular among locals. And the more popular a bar, the better the odds to find hook ups in Indianapolis.

Newfields Beer Garden is always adding new drinks to the menu, as well as offering classic favorites. These options include everything from draft to cider to eclectic bottled drinks. When you get hungry you can order a Giant Grilled Pretzel, shareable cheese charcuterie or one of their tasty veggie boards.

Play your cards right and you can be drinking a crisp beer while you enjoy a shareable dish with the woman of your dreams.

AFF is the easiest way to find Indianapolis hookups (try it free)

AFF has consistently been the fastest and easiest way that we've seen singles, especially guys, find hookups around Indianapolis. When you can actually meet people who just want to hook up 24/7 it's going to be hard for anything to beat it.

While it does have some competition from Tinder, particularly if you're quite good-looking, AFF has been the option that we've seen work the best for most guys. It has a TON of locals using it and it really is the only popular platform that is completely focused on fun in bed now that Tinder is basically more about dating these days.

With over 60 million active users that just want to skip the small talk and get to the fun stuff, it's something everyone in town needs to try (and a lot are). You can check out their free trial below and see. If you really want to find a solid stream of hookups you can't just look in bars and clubs! Be smart!

Try AFF For Free!
Using this link to AFF's free trial offer you can check out exactly why so many guys have had such great success finding hookups using it. It really is the best option for most guys that we've found, especially when you're not super good looking.

The best Indianapolis pickup bars we've tried

Whether you’re a cocktails expert or you rarely drink, the bar scene is always a social hot spot. Here are some of the best bars in the city for meeting sexy girls.

Bar One Fourteen is the classiest spot to meet girls near Purdue

A steak, burger and glass of champagne from Bar One Fourteen


The closer you get to the Purdue campus, the more the bars start to resemble dorm rooms. We like dive bars as much as the next guy, we do. But you tend to only meet girls who are using fake IDs at college bars. That scene isn’t for us anymore. Still, the upperclasswomen at Purdue are definitely some of the hottest single girls. We like any opportunity to mingle with some graduate-level babes.

For that purpose, we head to Bar One Fourteen, a classy speakeasy microbar for a hip clientele. Located in Meridian Kessler, Bar One Fourteen draws in all range of ladies. You’ll see your fair share of professional ladies, but it’s also a chic date night spot for the academic crowd. If you’re trying to impress your favorite nursing student on a first date, then take her here.

Even if you’re flying solo, Bar One Fourteen is a classy way to spend an evening and meet someone new. The bartenders make exquisite cocktails, and if you strike up a conversation with a hottie, we recommend sharing a small plate. Take it from us, Bar One Fourteen is one of the best places to meet cool girls.

The Rathskeller is the sunniest, best place to pick up girls

Young folks looking for Indianapolis hookups at The Rathskeller


It’s a scientific fact that the best time to find Indianapolis hookups in the daytime is on a warm, sunny day. We would show you the research, but we don’t want to bore you with all the details. The point is, bright, spring days are ideal for meeting cute girls just looking to have a good time. If you can mix in a little alcohol, you’ve got the perfect recipe for a perfect day. Enter: the beer garden that even Chicago girls love.

Drinking outdoors at the Rathskeller is by far one of the most enjoyable bar experiences in our city. For one thing, this part-bar/part-restaurant serves a mouthwatering assortment of old-world grub and German beer. The indoor dining room is a bit stuffy for our tastes, but the “biergarten” is basically heaven on earth. Order a dopplebock, dip a warm pretzel into hot mustard and enjoy a perfect day.

The best thing about beer gardens is they are the ideal place for meeting new people. The Rathskeller’s open-air “beer hall” is a relaxed, uncrowded spot for chatting up someone pretty. Plus, compared to most bars, the Rathskeller is by far more even in terms of gender. The only sausage party here is made with bratwurst.

Harry’s Chocolate Shop has something hot for your sweet tooth

An evening with friends at Harry’s Chocolate Shop


Whether you’re a student at Purdue or just a local, you surely know about Harry’s Chocolate Shop. For the collegiate crowd, it’s the best place to find Indianapolis hook ups. Even if your studying days are far behind you, though, this hot spot should still be on your personal curriculum.

Mixing classic bar grub with a cozy pub vibe, Harry’s Chocolate Shop has been an institution for a century. It’s a place old-timers still visit to relive their golden years, even as newbies keep finding it every year. If you’re hoping to meet single girls in, we can’t think of a more iconic – or reliable – spot.

Honorable Mention Bars

We’re a firm believer in the importance of keeping your options open. So here are a few more of our favorite bars for meeting girls. In case your search for Milwaukee hookups isn't working out, try these out:

The hookup apps in Indy dating coaches prefer

A huge number of hookups start online now. You don't have spend all day on the apps but spending 10-20 minutes a week sending messages can really pay off. These are the best hookup apps in the city right now:

SiteOur ExperienceOur RatingFree Trial Link
Best Hookup Site Right Now
Experience Highlights
Experience Highlights
  • Top option for local hookups by far
  • Best results for regular guys
  • Over 60 million active members
  • The design needs an update
Try AFF For Free
Great If You're Handsome
Tinder Highlights
Tinder Highlights
  • Great if you're pretty good looking
  • Very popular, especially if you're 18-22
  • Really focused on photos
  • Becoming more of a dating than hookup app
Try Tinder
2nd Best For Most Guys
Experience Highlights
Experience Highlights
  • 2nd best option to find hookups
  • Attracts an older crowd than most hookup apps
  • Pretty popular
  • Great free trial
Try Passion

The best clubs for finding hookups in Indianapolis

To dance or not to dance, that is the question. Even if you aren’t Fred Astaire, dance clubs are some of the most consistent spots for meeting sexy girls.

The Red Room has the sexiest girls every weekend

Beautiful women at The Red Room


Night clubs are like a siren call for sexy girls. These gals come to drink sweet cocktails, loosen up and shake it out on the dance floor. It’s as surefire a recipe for a good time as the gin and tonics they’re haphazardly throwing back. This means, if you’re not hitting up the clubs on the regular, you’re missing out on great opportunities.

Take the Red Room, for instance. Four nights a week, from Wednesday to Saturday, this charming, unpretentious club fills up with fun, bouncy girls. It’s a go-to spot for birthday outings and bachelorette parties. We hopefully don’t need to tell you those are exactly the types of outings you want to be around. Put down the can of PBR and put on your dancing shoes.

The great thing about the Red Room is that it makes it easy to mingle with hotties of all ages. Even if your dating game is a little rusty, you won’t feel intimidated chatting up new acquaintances. Better yet, shut your mouth and let your feet do the talking. The important thing is that you show up. Then the rest will sort itself out.

El Parral brings Latin spice to the city's nightlife

Girls on a night out at Parral


Nationally, our city doesn’t have a reputation for being a particularly diverse metropolis. But locals know that this city is absolutely hopping with varied cultures and entertainment for any tastes. Just head up I-65 to El Parral Night Club and you’ll see what we mean. This Latin hot spot is one of Indianapolis’ most lively and invigorating spots for eclectic DJs and late-night dancing.

For the hot girls who have rhythm to spare, El Parral is the place to be every weekend night. The dance floor is always shaking like an earthquake, whether there’s a DJ or live music. In fact, we highly recommend getting there on a night with live Latin music acts. It will seriously be one of the most fun nights you’ve had in our city, we guarantee it. Can't get laid in Minneapolis? Not a problem when you're here!

Don’t get it twisted: El Parral is for everyone. A Latin nightclub is one of the most welcoming places you’ll ever spend a night. Plus, all the sexy mamacitas are worth the drive away from downtown. Even if you can’t tell the difference between a salsa and a tango, give El Parral a visit. It’s easily the best place to pick up girls who will totally rock your world.

Hi-Fi doesn’t know how to have a boring night

A lively musical performance at Hi-Fi featuring a rock band


One of the best ways to meet single girls in is to go experience live music. As one of the most beloved independent music venues in the city, Hi-Fi draws in the hippest musical acts. On any given night, the concerts at this Virginia Avenue venue are overrun with cute, music-loving girls.

So forget the singles bars. Hi-Fi is where you’ll find the sexiest girls who know how to have fun and will party all night. Pick your night and you’ll find chicks for every taste: rockers, goths, punks, Manic Pixie Dream Girls. So if you’re a music lover, how could you not be here?

Honorable Mention Clubs

We’re confident you’ll love those two clubs, but it’s always good to have a few backups in mind. These additional clubs are always full of hot girls who want hook ups in Indianapolis. They're even great if you can't find hookups in St. Paul:

Best places to meet sexy Indianapolis girls during the day

Get Fit Athletic Club gets you in shape to restart your love life

Fitness instructors at the Get Fit Athletic Club


Has it been a while since your last relationship? Maybe you’ve been in the midst of a sexual dry spell? It can be exceedingly difficult to reset your love life when you’ve gotten complacent, both mentally and physically. One way to fix that is to get off your butt and sign up to the gym.

Get Fit Athletic Club on Washington Street is the smartest way to get yourself in shape. It has a large selection of options for working out, no matter your experience with fitness equipment. Even better, it’s a massive gym with a substantial clientele. We can’t think of a better environment for reawakening your body in all the ways that matter.

Coal Yard Coffee is as much an art house as a coffee house

Working and hanging out at Coal Yard Coffee


Down by Benton House, you’ll find one of our favorite hidden gems in our city. Coal Yard Coffee is a coffee house like no other. Lots of coffee shops have art on the walls. But few are more dedicated to exhibiting the quirky, cool and downright strange art of local artists. It’s like an art museum on Mars.

The atmosphere of Coal Yard Coffee is just part of the reason we love this place. For people who know Starbucks coffee is swill, this is the best place to find Indianapolis hookups. If you appreciate a well-made cup of joe – and like a gal who does to – then this is the place to go.

Other great hookup spots to get laid in Indianapolis

Once you've had your fill of searching for singles in the options, it's time to explore other ways of finding them. Try out these recommendations to find the hookup for you!

Did you know that Kroger is a great place to pick up women?

Options you can find at Kroger


We bet you heard someone say they met an attractive woman at the grocery store. This seems to be a common occurrence both in movies and in real life but hasn't quite made it into your list of places to find hookups in Indianapolis. Why not make that fantasy a reality at Kroger? And yeah, Fort Wayne has a branch too.

We think Kroger where you can get laid in Indianapolis for two reasons. One being because you are going to meet local women who are more likely to talk to you if they don’t think you are their scouting for women. And two, a lot of women actually go to the grocery store hoping they run into an attractive man. If that’s not motivation enough, we don’t know what is!

Tinder is how hot guys and sexy girls find hookups in Indianapolis

By this point, if you haven’t heard of Tinder, you better check your pulse. You may be dead. The platform that brought casual sex to your phone is an undeniable global phenomenon. We’d be surprised if you hadn’t tried it yet. But no list devoted to helping you meet hot girls would be complete without mentioning it. It works great in Indianapolis, but it's one of the best hookup apps in Detroit too!

Of course, if you have tried Tinder, then you probably already know the pros and cons. There is no other option with more hotties than Tinder. That’s the plus side. The downside is, if you yourself aren’t ridiculously good looking, the ladies will be swiping left. It’s really that simple: perfect 10s in our city use Tinder to find each other. So the rest of us have to work a little harder.

Coffeehouse Five is for charitable people (who also want to get laid in Indianapolis)

Several women meeting up at Coffeehouse Five


What better way to feel good about your conquest than to spend your money on a place that gives back? Coffeehouse Five is a for-benefit, and may we say absolutely delicious, coffee spot that you must check out. The owners of this coffee-mecca are so passionate about giving back that they give all their net revenue to support their community.

Finding real local hookups is a lot easier in a place that allows for a little conversation. Popular coffee houses, especially those that are open late, are really great places to meet a lot of single women. They're usually open-minded and hopped up on caffeine so don't expect to go to bed early!

This Indianapolis coffee house made our list not only for their charitable donations but also because of their inviting menu. The coffee and espresso options are to die for, and the dessert options are out of this world. It is no wonder so many locals frequent Coffeehouse Five to fill all of their tasty desires.

If industrial chic interior is your vibe and you’re craving a delicious beverage while looking to get laid in Indianapolis, Coffeehouse Five is where you need to hang out.

Map of our favorite places to find hookups and meet girls

In order to make things a lot easier for you to plan we've put all of our favorite spots in Indianapolis on the map below. As you can see, it isn't too tough to try out multiple places in a night. If you really want to get a lot of success with girls you're going to need to bounce around a bit.

Frequently Asked Questions on Hookups in Indianapolis

How to find hookups in Indianapolis?

The best way to find hookups in Indianapolis is to visit local bars and clubs such as:

  • Newsfields Beer Garden
  • Bar One Fourteen
  • The Rathskeller
  • Harry's Chocolate Shop

Or if you're not really into going out every Friday, you can try using some dating apps like AFF or eHarmony.

What is the best hookup site for Indianapolis?

The best hookup site in Indianapolis is AFF (AdultFriendFinder). It's literally designed for hookups and not just casual dating or serious dating. It's the best place to find a one-night stand or maybe even a friend with benefits.

If you liked this check out these other great spots for hookups:

Next - Previous

Join Our Newsletter

No Spam. Just Higher Dating Success.

Leave a Comment