12 Spots and Bars To Find Beautiful Cougars In Indianapolis in 2020

Cougars in Indianapolis Indiana enjoying beers at a brewery

Going out with the intent of having a good time and meeting cougars in Indianapolis makes total sense with a huge number of choices for dining and fun around the corner.

From the fancy desserts at the Gallery Pastry Shop to the beautiful gardens at the Garfield Gardens Conservancy, Indianapolis provides you with multiple options to enjoy the remarkable Hoosier culture.

Tucked in the east of Ohio, Indianapolis is without a doubt a beautiful place to spot cougars–you just have to know where to look. That’s what we’re here for. Below are places where you can meet cougars, land dates and enjoy more shagging in Indianapolis.

Spots Where You Can Find Cougars in Indianapolis

Look for a pack of older women hanging out in these places and tell us how it went. We’d love to hear your experiences.

Slippery Noodle for tasty drinks and exciting Indianapolis cougars


Slippery Noodle for tasty drinks and exciting Indianapolis cougars

Situated in the corner of the Wholesale District is The Slippery Noodle, Naptown’s oldest bar.

Originally opened as Tremont House in the 1800s, this iconic bar offers an easygoing and relaxing vibe, perfect for sipping a drink and picking up single cougars in Indianapolis.

Grab drinks for half of the price during Thursdays and be sure to devour their sample platter with hot Buffalo wings, mozzarella sticks and chicken strips.

With its weekly drink specials and occasional live music performances, the Slippery Noodle is a great place to enjoy good food, find great women and have an incredible time.

Indianapolis cougars in this place are normally on the prowl, so don’t be afraid to make eye contact. Forget the coy gazes and the games. Watch out for their deadly pounce.

Homepage for Adult Friend Finder

Guys who just want to jump into bed need to use Adult FriendFinder first (try it free)

Indianapolis is a great city, but it’s definitely a little more on the conservative side. Guys who want to meet an Indianapolis cougar for a fling have a pretty tough time. That is until they use Adult FriendFinder.

We don’t recommend many sites or apps for guys who are just looking for sex but when we do it’s usually Adult FriendFinder. We have just seen so many more guys find what they are looking for compared to the other options out there that it’s hard to recommend another app. Sure, it isn’t perfect, but it’s the best option for most guys out there right now.

This is our most dependable way to meet cougars to take home around the city!

From our experience, Adult FriendFinder has the most women 30+ using it and all the women on the site are looking for sex. In fact, finding a casual partner is the whole point of the site. Unlike Tinder, which is full of people in their 20's and is basically just a normal relationship site these days, AFF is more focused on sex.

Guys looking for cougars in Indianapolis should check out their free trial and see the women available in their area. Spend a little time online, check out the Indianapolis cougar bars on our list and try out other great places for sexy Indianapolis meetups. When you do all three, you’re sure to have a blast!

Try AFF For Free


St. Elmo Steak House for a great fine dining experience with a cougar in Indianapolis


St. Elmo Steak House for a great fine dining experience

Known for its lush steaks and fresh seafood, St. Elmo Steak House offers an extreme combo of delicate foods and intense pleasure. Learning how to meet cougars around town is hard enough without some great food to try. Don't miss out because of low blood sugar!

With cozy armchairs and great lighting, this upscale pub creates a fire-lit atmosphere that encourages visitors to spend hours at the bar for classic drinks and elegant martinis. It’s the type of ambiance cougars can’t resist.

Have a sip of their globally-recognized Elmo Cola, which is a mix of Madagascar vanilla beans, cherries and bourbon. You can also try the Gouda mac-n-cheese or the succulent New York strip to satiate your appetite. St. Elmo also has great desserts lined up. We recommend the chocolate cake and the blueberry bread pudding to finish the meal.

Hang out in the bar upstairs and find some classy cougars who want a little more pleasure than the food can offer.


Cougar Life is our favorite way for most guys to meet cougars in Indianapolis for a relationship (try it free)

Homepage for Cougar Life

There are several great options to meet cougars in Indianapolis when you're going out but you only have so much time and money you can spend. If you REALLY want to meet a lot of single cougars you need to be smart and efficient with your time. That means checking out Cougar Life's free trial.

A lot of cougars have stopped spending time in bars and clubs and ONLY meeting single guys online. They're busy too and being able to connect with men, especially when they want to date younger guys, makes their life (and your life) a LOT easier.

If you haven't tried out online dating yet to meet cougars you're missing out on a TON of opportunities!

There are a few reasons why we've found Cougar Life to be the best option for most guys and why it's at the top of our rankings for the best cougar dating apps and sites:

You won't find more Indianapolis cougars on any other site or app

There are other options out there that have more people using them but actually finding single cougars can be very time-consuming. Even if you find attractive women over 35 using them you never really know if they're interested in dating younger guys.

With Cougar Life, every woman using it is VERY open to dating both younger and older guys and they aren't afraid to show it! No other option out there has more REAL COUGARS that you can actually meet up with.

Younger guys won't do better anywhere else

Cougar Life is great for older guys who want to date cougars but younger guys will be especially pleased with it. There is still a big stigma with women about dating younger guys in a lot of places and Cougar Life does a great job of making women feel comfortable with their desires.

No other option comes anywhere close to being as effective for guys who want to date older women!

Instead of worrying that the women you're messaging MIGHT be interested in a younger guy you know she is. Don't be surprised if you actually get older women messaging you first for once either!

These women actually want to meet up and there's a great variety

It doesn't matter how many people are using an app or site if all the women are just there for attention. Most of the bigger free apps out there are filled with time-wasting women who just want to collect compliments.

In our experience, the women on Cougar Life are MUCH more engaged and actually want to meet guys in person. Why else would they use such a specific site? There is also a great mix of women who want short-term fun and those who want an actual relationship. You can pick and choose.

If you haven't tried out Cougar Life's free trial you absolutely should. It's a great experience for most guys and a combination of time spend in our favorite places on this list and Cougar Life is a recipe for success!

Try Cougar Life For Free


Kilroy Bar N’ Grill for viewing parties and spotting Indianapolis cougars


Kilroy Bar N’ Grill for viewing parties and spotting Indianapolis cougars

Sports lovers go to Kilroy for their affordable delicacies, excellent drinks and regular viewing parties. Try their classic and BBQ sliders to start. Then accompany it with a grilled chicken breast or a flat iron steak. Unlike any other kitchenettes in Indianapolis, Kilroy only serves fresh meats directly sourced from the butcher shop.

CD image

Aside from the food, you also need to go to Kilroy for the cougars. Simmer down in the seats available outside. But be advised that the incredible agility and sharp sensibility of cougars in Indianapolis may weaken your knees and tame your beast. All you need to do is glance at her and she might pounce!

Homepage for EH

Single cougars on eHarmony want long-term relationships (try it now)

Older single women around Indianapolis tend to be busy and they don’t have as much time in their hectic schedules to be going out to places like bars or clubs. Online dating doesn’t take up nearly as much time as going out does, so that’s where a huge number of these cougars are looking.

If you haven’t tried online dating or it’s been a while since you have, you’re missing out on meeting a lot of different women, particularly if you’re looking for relationship-ready cougars.  The question you might be asking now is which site these women are looking on.

We’re always looking for the next best cougar dating site or app. We’ve tried many over the years, but our favorite site for finding attractive older women has been eHarmony (and you can try it out right now here). We just haven't been able to find another site the can delivery anywhere close to the results we had using it.

So, just what is it about eHarmony that makes it so great and why? For starters, it has a lot of single cougars using it. They have over 30 million active members and the best female to male ratio of any major site. That means more options and women who aren't being bombarded by 100 messages a day.

This coupled with the fact that after nearly twenty years of successfully matching up singles and collecting data, they’ve really, really fine-tuned their algorithm. No other site has eHarmony’s level of matching technology or the ability to match up compatible men and women.

eHarmony is responsible for nearly 75% of all online dating relationships that lead to marriage. Over 300% more than any other site!

It also requires its users to fill out more thorough profiles than most other dating apps and sites, so the members who stick around tend to be a little more serious about dating. In other words, they’re not JUST looking around or seeking validation for their sexy selfies (Tinder, anyone?). This makes the cougars WAY more responsive to your messages and dates than you will find anywhere else. It's a great experience.

We could easily go on and on about how great eHarmony is, but you need to see for yourself why it's so great. Give their proven trial a shot. It really is the best site for finding attractive older women in Indianapolis. It's easy for normal guys to use and you can't expect to get new results without trying new things!

Try eHarmony Free


Ikea and Jonesy’s for friendly chats and fun times with cougars in Indianapolis


Ikea and Jonesy’s for friendly chats and fun times

With a great selection of beers and liquor, Ikea and Jonesy expresses a casual, no-strings-attached vibe--perfect for hunting cougars in Indianapolis. From Monday to Saturday, you can find DJs spinning lively tracks that will make you want to get out there and dance. Impress the cougars with your dance moves--they play anything from the latest tracks to some golden oldies.

Here you’ll meet groups of 35+ women enjoying get-togethers like birthday parties, corporate events or even bachelorette parties. So, get down there pronto and you’ll be sure to meet some lovely mature ladies who will be more than happy to chat.

Also, be on the lookout for Ikea’s insane deals throughout the week. On some days, beers are only priced at $2.50. And on Fridays, you can devour Stoli Flavors & Jim Beam for just $5.

The Northside Social for good food and great conversation with cougars in Indianapolis


The Northside Social for good food and great conversation

You can find this fun bar at the northern end of Broad Ripple Village. The friendly atmosphere will put you right at home straight away, and the home-cooked comfort food is fantastic. The Northside Social specializes in Mediterranean, Caribbean and traditional Southern cuisines, so you can fuel up for a great night ahead.

Designed with contemporary interiors and clean white lines, The Northside Social expresses an industrial feel that lures Indianapolis cougars nearby. These ladies just love crisp, classy interiors paired with good food and even better drinks!

Champps for fresh food, Indianapolis cougars and an action-packed atmosphere


Champps for fresh food and an action-packed atmosphere

Similar to Kilroy, Champps is also a sports bar but with a little twist into it. With its decor, this fun chain restaurant is where cougars in Indianapolis gather for corporate events, birthday parties and get-togethers.

Savor their mouth-watering pasta dishes, chicken, well-cooked steaks and salads that will forsooth your cravings. Occasionally, Champps treats customers with discounts on their burgers. So before heading to the place, visit their social media pages to eat more and pay less.

So why do Indianapolis cougars love it here? Simple, it’s the fun neighborhood bar where you’re friends with everyone. These lovely older ladies love the vibe and you can take advantage of that by being the friendly newcomer who will buy them a drink!

Get wet and wild with Indianapolis cougars at Ricks Cafe Boatyard


Get wet and wild at Ricks Cafe Boatyard

Appreciate a beautiful Indianapolis night on the waterside at Ricks Café Boatyard. If you prefer a calmer and more relaxed atmosphere, Ricks Cafe Boatyard will suit you down to the ground. They offer a great menu with fine dining options if that’s more your style.

Here you can check out the fine older ladies while also enjoying the breathtaking views of the water outside. Grab yourself a whiskey blues and bring along a glass of Bahama Mama for a hot momma lounging on the terrace.

Beyondages.com video course

Find a sporty cougar at The District Tap

Watch all the big games on an even bigger screen at The District Tap. Take pleasure in drinking over 60 varieties of craft beers, signature salads like apple walnut, strawberry fried salad and red-hot gorgeous broods.

Come here to watch an NFL game and expect a loud, buzzing atmosphere with plenty of Indianapolis cougars waiting for their moment to strike up a conversation with a passionate sports fan.

The Jazz Kitchen attracts sultry sophisticated ladies who know what they want

Put on your best blazer, apply your most expensive perfume and head down to the Jazz Kitchen for an evening of excellent music and a sexy, seductive atmosphere. Classy cougars in Indianapolis simply love this joint with its great live music and elegant vibe.

Here you can have a good time listening to authentic jazz music performed by talented Hoosier musicians. Once the music simmers down, that’s your cue to approach one of the gorgeous cougars at the bar. Offer to buy her a drink and see where the night takes you.

The Red Room is for classy conversation and cool cocktails

The Red Room describes itself as an upscale ultra-lounge experience. Here you can expect trendy cocktails, fine wine and even finer cougars. Expect to find groups of intelligent, attractive older ladies sipping on martinis and enjoying the refined atmosphere.

As night draws, this bar transforms into a packed dance club where you can show off your moves. Get your dancing shoes on and impress the cougars as you get up close and personal. The next thing you know, you will be both boogieing at your place.

The Indianapolis Cougar Bars To Check Out

You can meet women like this at cougar bars in Indianapolis

Meet a wild cat tonight at these Indianapolis cougar bars.

Find a new whiskey and get a little frisky at Whiskey Business

Cherish good times and meet cougars at the Whiskey Business. Considered as one of the trendiest cougar bars in Indianapolis, Whiskey Business is not only a home for top-class drinks but also to great American comfort food like burgers, pasta dishes and healthy desserts.

Start chatting with one of the ladies at the bar by asking them what their favorite whiskey is. Get into a friendly debate and offer to buy her your favorite to prove your point. And once you’re a little tipsy, let her know that you find her attractive. After all, as the age-old adage goes, whiskey, like beautiful women needs appreciation.

Find a delicious cougar dish at Petite Chau Bistro & Champagne Bar

There’s just something so chic about all things French and Petite Chau Bistro & Champagne Bar is no exception. With its extensive menu, this place offers you a look at the Parisian culinary scene. It’s also a great place to meet Indianapolis cougars, especially ones who don’t leave the house without their pooch.

Find a cougar sitting at the patio with her dog. Compliment her furry companion as you ask if she’d like to share a bottle of champagne. And if she asks what’s the occasion, tell her that it’s not every day you get to share the company of such a beautiful woman.

Wine and dine with some gorgeous women at Tastings

Tastings is just one of those places you need to go if you’re a wine lover and looking for someone with similar interests. If you’re looking discover new wines and new mature women, then look no further!

At Tastings, whether your knowledge of wine is limited or broad, you’ll never feel like an outsider. With great tasting menus, you can easily discuss wine that you’ve just discovered with a beauty across the way. From there you can chat about the wines that you both have tried. Subtly order her favorite wine and she’s sure to appreciate it.

Cougars and wine go together like nothing else. So if you want to learn about wine while meeting older women with refined tastes, nothing beats Tastings.

You need to try this

Meet a cougar who’s just visiting at Plat 99

Located in The Alexander Hotel in Indianapolis, Plat 99 offers great drinks, nibbles and a relaxed environment for meeting women. From locally sourced meats, fresh seafood and home-made pasta, Plat 99 offers cuisines that highlight the rich flavors and culinary traditions of Italy.

Since it’s located in a hotel, you can expect to find lots of out-of-town cougars at Plat 99. These cougars are known to go on the prowl when they’re in a new city. So try chatting up one of them, and who knows, she might invite you upstairs.

Expand your tastes and meet an Indianapolis cougar at The Capital Grille

At Capital Grille, the food is refined and the women are even better. If you’re looking for a fantastic meal and some great company, this will be the place to find it. It’s a classy place that offers a fantastic fine dining experience. And sophisticated spots like this only attract chic cougars with good taste. Dress sharp, prepare your wallet and get ready to mingle with a posh cougar who’s got a wild side!

For more recommendations check out more great guides to meet cougars:

Previous Guide - Next Guide

Join Our Newsletter For Exclusive Dating Tips & Advice
No Spam.
Just Higher Dating Success.

Leave a Comment