When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

2024's Top 5 Port St. Lucie Dating Apps and Sites (What Works)

Port St. Lucie, Florida is, as we found it, a quiet, outdoorsy city that seemed like a great place to retire. If you’re used to the wilder party atmospheres of bigger cities, you might find PSL boring, as it’s quite sleepy and the locals like it that way. Still, there’s a dating scene to be explored and enjoyed—if you have the right Port St. Lucie dating apps helping you out, that is.

Even in the biggest cities in the country, the recent pandemic changed the dating scene drastically. A great number of singles turned to online dating to find the people, dates, and relationships they wanted. And in sleepy towns like PSL, you can imagine how invaluable dating apps became.

Despite the golf courses and great outdoors drawing tourists and locals alike, Port St. Lucie still has that “retirement” vibe, and you’ll likely have a hard time playing the dating game without apps. And that’s why we prepared a list of the best dating apps in Port St. Lucie, Florida just for you.

Before we jump to it, you might want to check out the best dating apps for these other great cities in Florida:






The 5 Best Dating Sites in Port St. Lucie Right Now

As always, we picked our recommendations using simple criteria—they got us the results we wanted. We tested all the major apps and sites to see which ones were the best in two categories: short-term dating and long-term.

The quality and number of matches, the usability of the app or site, and the success rate all factored into our scoring system. These five dating sites and apps top our list and should make your foray into Port St. Lucie’s dating scene more enjoyable.

#1 - eHarmony (Android, iOS) is one of the best dating apps in Port St. Lucie for serious relationships

eHarmony screenshots iOS

eHarmony is bar none the best dating app to use if you’re looking for something serious. Port St. Lucie’s reputation as an ideal place to settle down seems to precede itself, and we found a good-sized userbase on eHarmony while we were there.

The matches we got on eHarmony were quite on-point with what we were looking for, owing largely to eHarmony’s long signup process. More like a test than a signup process, it weeds out the time-wasters, leaving only serious daters on the platform. Because of this, nearly 75% of users find their future spouse within a year of using the app!

Why eHarmony is great

  • Fantastic track record in helping people find their future spouses
  • The app is easy to use
  • Lots of high-quality matches

What we don't like about it

  • The signup process, while worth it, is rigorous
  • The app design can be improved



#2 - Plenty of Fish (Android, iOS) is a solid second choice in Port St. Lucie

Plenty of Fish on iOS

Plenty of Fish is one of the older online dating services out there, and it still maintains a sizeable following nationwide. It was no surprise, then, that it performed quite well in a retirement town like Port St. Lucie.

Plenty of Fish attracts users who are slightly older, more mellow, and more interested in serious relationships. If that sounds like what you’re looking for, then good old PoF is worth a try.

Why Plenty of Fish is great

  • Plenty of users in Port St. Lucie
  • The app is familiar enough to use

What we don't like about it

  • The quality of users can be disappointing
  • App design is a bit cluttered



#3 – AFF is the best dating site in Port St. Lucie for casual flings and FWBs (try it free)

AFF homepage

Meanwhile, if you’re not looking for a serious relationship, and instead just want some good, consensual fun with like-minded people in PSL, then AFF (which you can try free here) should top your list. Yes, some Port St. Lucie locals just want to have fun, too, and they’ll love to meet you on AFF.

It’s hard to beat AFF at what it does. It focuses 100% on matching people for casual flings, one-night stands, and friends-with-benefits relationships. And as it is in most other parts of the country, it does this very well.

Why AFF is great

  • 50 million+ users mean you’ll find quite a number of matches right off the bat
  • All age ranges are well-represented
  • The best option for a lot of guys

What we don't like about it

  • Some features are clunky
  • With so many matches, you’ll need some extra time sorting through your search results
You Can Try AFF Free!
If you're just looking for more short-term fun you need to try out AFF. We've spent months and months testing out the alternatives (more than 100 other sites) and haven't found anything that gives most guys more options and better results. Give it a shot!


Match.com on Android

Match is one of the more general online dating services out there and has a sizeable userbase in Port St. Lucie. You’re just as likely to find users looking for long-term commitment as those who want short-term fun. And that’s great when you’re not 100% sure what you want out of the dating game just yet.

Why Match is great

  • You stand a pretty good chance at finding what you want, no matter what it might be
  • The signup process is easy and straightforward
  • The app rewards users who have good photos and writing skills

What we don't like about it

  • With the broad userbase, you may need some extra time sorting through your matches
  • You’ll likely go through a few dud matches



#5 - Bumble (Android, iOS) adds an interesting twist to meeting new people

Bumble on iOS

Bumble only lets women initiate conversations, which means two things. First, the ladies can relax, knowing they’re only going to interact with the men they find interesting and appealing. Second, the men can focus on setting up attractive, enticing profiles and wait for the ladies to reach out to them.

Perhaps owing to the fact that there are more women than men in Port St. Lucie, we got better results here than in most other towns. If Bumble’s dynamic seems interesting to you, I suggest you try it out.

Why Bumble is great

  • Bumble’s system tends to lead to better interactions with matches
  • Popular with women who like to take the lead
  • If you’re an attractive guy with good profile-writing skills, you can sit back and wait for the messages to roll in

What we don't like about it

  • If you’re a guy who tends to stand out through messaging, you won’t be very lucky here
  • You likewise won’t find much success if you’re not good at writing profiles



The Best Hookup Sites in Port St. Lucie

Posing by the window

So, what are the best hookup sites in Port St. Lucie? Here are two that we’ve always considered top-notch.

AFF is for singles who are serious about hooking up

AFF just outshines the competition when it comes to matching you with people who also want some short-term sexy fun.

For a long time, it’s been thought that Tinder was the premier app in the casual relationship space. Today, AFF holds that title for two main reasons: (1) Tinder has morphed into a more general dating service, with more and more people starting to find true love on the platform; and (2) while Tinder is dominated by younger users, AFF has members of all ages.

AFF also boasts one of the largest English-speaking user-base in online dating, with over 50 million users and growing. The ease with which you’ll find like-minded matches will show you why it’s one of the best casual dating sites in Port St. Lucie.

Tinder works too if you have great photos

Despite the changes it has recently gone through, Tinder is still going strong as one of the top Port St. Lucie hookup sites. If you don’t mind matching with younger people and dealing with the occasional flake, then Tinder is a solid backup app to have. Just make sure you have a profile that will really catch people's eye. Swiping tends to happen fast, so if your profile is meh, you'll likely get ignored.

The Best Dating Sites in Port St. Lucie

A couple on a date at the beach

What about dating sites? If you’re looking for true love, what are the Port St. Lucie dating sites/apps to use? Without a doubt, you should first turn to...

eHarmony: the top dating app in Florida

eHarmony pulls out all the stops to create a safe, rewarding experience for all its users. Its long, tedious (yet super-meaningful) signup process ensures none of the scammers and time-wasters get through.

And it works—to date, more than 600,000 happy couples around the world attest to having first met on eHarmony. And the numbers show that if you stuck to the platform for at least a year, there’s a 70% chance you, too, will find “the one.” That’s what makes it one of the best dating sites/apps in Port St. Lucie.

Coffee Meets Bagel is for busy daters

If you’re a bit too busy for that kind of time commitment, you might want to try Coffee Meets Bagel. Popular with young professionals, it lets you sort through a shortlist of matches every single day—and no more. You’ll spend less time searching and more time going on dates.

The Best Free Dating Sites in Port St. Lucie

Testing out a dating app

Do you need to buy an app’s premium services to find a date? The answer is “no,” but it does make the process ten times easier. With apps, you get what you pay for, and that goes double for dating apps.

Premium services can mean more search filters, more “swipes,” the ability to see who likes you, and more. If you’re sure you don’t need the bells and whistles to find the people and dates you want, then we suggest you stick to the best free dating sites in Port St. Lucie:

  • OkCupid
  • Tinder
  • Facebook Dating

So, go ahead—find the dating apps that work for you, and enjoy the quiet scenery of Port St. Lucie with great people. Good luck!

Join Our Newsletter

No Spam. Just Higher Dating Success.

Leave a Comment