The 9 Best Dating Apps In New York For Proven Success in 2021

New York City woman using a dating app in the parkIt’s no secret that dating in New York is difficult. Dating here is so stressful that it can sometimes make you want to quit altogether. It’s frustrating to see fresh New York City dating apps pop up frequently with no way to actually improve your dating life. Only a small number of these apps stay in business in the long run. Dating apps that promise to revolutionize the world from Manhattan to Vinegar Hill pop up all the time, leaving the singles to feel defeated.

Believe it or not, some dating apps in New York city actually work. You’re not looking for love in Poughkeepsie, after all. Even if most of your time is spent with your nose in the books at NYU or the City College of New York, you’re bound to find some single, attractive people who will match your schedule with the right dating app.

Equipped with the wrong tools, you might just waste your time. But when used the right way, dating apps can help speed up the whole process. There is no better option for meeting fun and attractive people in New York. With so many options ranging from specifically-tailored interests to more general apps, you’ve got tons of choices.

We’ve listed the best dating apps in New York as found through our own research and feedback from local friends. Try them out and leave a comment about the experience. With almost 40% of New York’s 8,600,000-strong population being single, you’re bound to find find the one that’s destined for you!

The Best New York City  Dating Apps Right Now

After we look at the apps geared towards specific tastes we can take a look at the best general dating apps for New York.

If you’re a man looking to date older women or a woman looking for younger men, you have to give Cougar Life a try

Cougar Life is the best dating app to meet women over 35

New York has no shortage of attractive older women. Spend any time in Manhattan and you’ll know what I mean. If you’re ready to try something different, start with Cougar Life’s free trial.

This app was made for men who want to date women over 30 and women who want a variety of different men. It can be really tough to meet a single older woman when you are out in the city. These women are extremely busy and don't hang out in typical bars and clubs.

Instead, they have been going online to be able to meet guys 24/7, especially if they are interested in younger guys. Each year we list off our favorite cougar dating apps and Cougar Life has been the top choice in the city for the past several years.

Give the app a shot and see how it goes. You might find a happy ending to your perpetual singledom! We have put together more solid places to meet New York City cougars if you want a few more suggestions.

Try Cougar Life For Free


College graduates in New York who want like-minded people must give Elite Singles a shot

Elite Singles is the best dating app to meet people with college degrees

With NYU and CCNY around, it’s no surprise that 36% of the NYC population has a college degree. If you’re looking for someone who has a degree like yourself, the odds of that happening are pretty good.

You probably spent so much time and effort getting your own college degree, so it only makes sense to seek out a partner with the same shared experience. While Elite Singles has not been around for long, it’s growing to be more effective for singles in NYC.

Instead of filtering through hoards of people, unsure of who did or didn’t attend college, you can find a bunch of people with similar experiences all in one app.

Try Elite Singles For Free


Adult FriendFinder's free trial is the best if you just want a quick fling

Homepage for the best adult dating app Adult FriendFinderThere are a lot of apps out there that claim to be able to make short-term, no strings attached fun easy. When it really comes down to it there are only two options that work. We will talk about Tinder and it’s limitations in a bit but first want to talk about how Adult FriendFinder is the app that is going to be most useful for the vast majority of people out there.

Adult FriendFinder isn’t the newest app around. Luckily, they have the huge benefit of being by far the largest app of its type (aside from Tinder) with over 25 MILLION visits a month. That’s a lot of people looking for flings!

This is the best option around town if you are looking for a more physical relationship above all else. There are very few apps out there that can actually deliver and Adult FriendFinder is the one we have seen work for the most people most consistently. The big reason is that they actually get a lot of interested women using the app. Almost no other app can say that and it really shows in their results. You can check them out for free and see what we mean.

Every year we put together a full review of all the best hookup apps out there and AFF has been the best choice for most people for a while. You want to have the most opportunities possible and an app that helps connect you with people interested in the same things. AFF does both splendidly.

These types of apps definitely are not for everyone. They are 100% focused on helping men and women find other people to meet up with quickly and easily. If you are tired of frequenting bars and clubs and just want to get down to business, check Adult FriendFinder out. All the other “fling apps” are a complete waste of time.

Adult FriendFinder is especially good if you are looking to meet people over 30 (or are 30+ yourself). It is still great for the younger crowd but there is nothing better for those with a little more experience.

Try Adult FriendFinder For Free!
If you haven't tried it yet, you need to check out Adult Friend Finder's free trial offer with this link and see for yourself. We've tried out and ranked over 100 different sites and apps and most guys have done better here than anywhere else. There isn't an easier option out there.


Single parents in New York must try eHarmony to keep their options open

eHarmony is the best app for single parents

Single parents know more than anyone else how difficult dating can be. There’s something uniquely comforting about spending time with other single parents who have been through it all too. With over 12 million single-parent households taking up space in the United States, you know a good chunk of them are in New York. If you're a guy who is always running out of good things to talk about with a girl on the phone or in-person a site like eHarmony can give you some breathing room and allow you to be your best self.

As a dating single parent, bigger is better. The wider the net you cast, the better your catches will be. Signing up for eHarmony requires a bit more work than other sites, but those few minutes you spend will help you get matches that are actually worth your time.

With over 15 million people using eHarmony, most people find good matches. You can save hours filtering through singles with this app, making it extremely valuable for busy single parents.

Single guys who want more options to meet a New York MILF will be especially happy here. There are few ways that make it faster or easier.

Try eHarmony Now


If you’re (really) attractive and just want a fling, Tinder is the best option

Logo for Tinder app

Tinder is probably best known as a last resort for finding a fling. While this is true and can be helpful, there is a lot to watch out for on the site and it can be a great way to find New York hookups.

For starters, if you’re not a super attractive guy, you’re not going to stand out using Tinder. This will quickly prove to be disappointing as women ignore you because they’re swamped with other thirsty men who give the rest a bad rap.

Women might get a good ego boost from the app before deciding to never log back in. The guys on Tinder tend to hit women up constantly, which can turn some ladies off the app altogether.

If you’re looking for more than a one-night stand or you’re not mega-attractive, don’t waste your time on Tinder. It isn't one of the top-rated apps out there for most people but some can do great. Other apps can give you better results in less time.

Try Tinder For Free


Large ladies and the men who love them in New York need eHarmony

Big, beautiful women and the men who want to date them have got to make eHarmony their first stop. If you haven’t had much luck on other sites, eHarmony could be the perfect solution, especially if you're also spending some time in our favorite spots to meet a BBW in New York.

Sadly, BBWs often leave dating apps because of the competition they feel with other women. This means the men who are looking to date them lose interest too because they can’t find what they want.

eHarmony does a fantastic job because they have a HUGE number of people using it. The site only matches you up with BBW who are looking for someone like you.

When you can use an extremely popular dating app that does all the work for you it's something special and is a big reason most guys have the best success with BBW using it.

eHarmony is the perfect solution because it provides a platform for men and women with the same interests to meet up and date within a bigger pool. This streamlines the process and prevents further stress from trying out different dating apps.

The best Christian dating app in New York is Christian Mingle

When you’re a dedicated Christian, dating can prove to be a huge challenge. So many people claim to share your values only for you to find out that it’s all for show. Narrowing down the people who practice what they preach can be more difficult than you think.

Nothing is worse than meeting someone special and thinking you share the same faith, only to later discover you differ in your beliefs. Now you’ve both wasted each other’s time. Too much energy gets invested without any return. Thankfully there are dating apps to help mitigate this.

Christian Mingle helps you dodge some of the worst parts of dating as a Christian in New York. Rather than wade through a sea of people who don’t care about their faith, you can find loads of fellow Christians who have the same values as you.

Ditch that church social group and go out to meet some new people through Christian Mingle!

People dating over the age of 50 in New York need Our Time

Dating doesn’t get any easier as you age, especially not in New York. In fact, dating above the age of 50 is incredibly difficult at times. Dating apps for this demographic are becoming surprisingly popular. The signup process is simplified, and some apps even make the user experience as easy as possible.

Singles over 50 in New York might enjoy using Our Time. This popular app is great for the older generation because it is easy to use, even for people who struggle to work with technology.

If you don’t know anything about dating apps when you’re above 50 years old, give Our Time a try. The process will not be intimidating.

General New York City Dating Apps To Consider

With the best options for specific dating apps behind us, we can now take a look at the best general dating apps in New York.

For more than a fling, you should check out eHarmony

No apps compare to eHarmony when you look at how thorough and accurate they are. Rather than fill out a brief biography and picture, makes you put in a little more work from the start.

With a more complete profile, your matches will be more accurate. A couple of minutes of extra work can change the entire scope of your success and also weed out the people who don’t care about dating enough to fully fill out a profile.

OkCupid and Plenty of Fish are good options with some caveats

Of course, our list of best New York dating City apps would not be complete if we forgot OKC and Plenty of Fish. These apps are so popular that most people have used them at one point or another.

They have large pools of people, which widens the possibilities. With the number of users on the site, their actual activity rate is surprisingly low. We have yet to see another app with activity per subscriber as minimal as OKC and POF.

While taking extra time to perfect your profile can help, you’re better off spending time on different apps that will yield better results.

If you are looking for more great guides to finding the right dating apps check these out:


Join Our Newsletter For Exclusive Dating Tips & Advice
No Spam.
Just Higher Dating Success.

Leave a Comment