When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.
2025 Milftastic Review - Are There Really MILFs Here?
In our Milftastic review, we’ll go over whether there are really MILFs, cougars, or sugar mamas hanging out on Milftastic.com or if this site is a total waste of time. After checking out 100+ other dating sites, we decided to give Milftastic an honest try to see what the women were like.
There are tons of dating apps out there where you could potentially meet MILFs. But you have to weed through so many profiles to find the right woman. We specifically wanted to check out Milftastic to see if it’s easier to meet MILFs.
The Best Apps to Meet MILFs For Regular Guys According To Dating Coaches
If you’ve been struggling to meet cougars, there is a very good chance you’re just using the wrong app. These are the best apps right now to meet them for regular guys that our team of dating experts recommends. Try them first if you want to find quick success:
| Site | Our Experience | Our Rating | Free Trial Link |
|---|---|---|---|
Best Hookup Site For MILFs  | Experience Highlights
| 9 | Try AFF For Free |
Best For Relationships  | Experience Highlights
| 9 | Try eHarmony |
2nd Best For Hookups  | Experience Highlights
| 8 | Try Passion |
If you are reading this review you understand the importance of getting an expert opinion before making a decision. We wanted to do the work necessary to verify whether Milftastic has real women who are ready to have a good time.
It is incredibly important to test out both the free and paid of a site, as we did with Milftastic. Sometimes one version is the better value and you can’t determine that without checking them both out. A lot of other reviews only look at the free version which is usually not the best indicator of the results you can get!
Grab a drink for this one, gentlemen, because Milftastic has been a wild experience.
Our Thorough Milftastic Review
For the Milftastic review, we went in with the mindset that we’d like to meet some older women. Let’s say, age 35+. They’re the type of woman who’s on the more mature side but need a little extra fun in their life.
Side note: If you’ve never heard of the term MILF, it means “mother I’d like to f***.” Think of the classic song “Stacey’s Mom” or Stifler’s mom from American pie.
Below is a quick comparison rating with AFF (which is the highest rated site for meeting MILFs looking to hook up we have found). Note that the ratings are not between these two sites specifically. Instead, it’s how we’d rate Milftastic compared to the other dating sites we’ve tried.
 |
 |
|
|---|---|---|
| Overall Our team rates each site objectively based on many hours of independent research, the features each site offers, and how it compares with other sites. The ratings are the opinion of our editors and their extensive experience. |
1 | 9.5 |
| Quality of Women Our opinion of how attractive the typical woman is that uses this site and how easy they are to connect with compared to other sites. |
2 | 9 |
| Popular How many people are using this site to actually meet people compared to other sites. |
1 | 9 |
| Usability How easy is this site to use and how quickly can an average person begin meeting people compared to other sites. |
5 | 10 |
| Privacy & Safety Does this site take proper precautions to safeguard its members, their identity, and their data. |
1 | 9 |
| Effective Our opinion of how easily an average person will be able to achieve their dating goals with this site compared to other sites. |
1 | 9 |
| Value Will the time and money spent using this site pay off for an average person based on the opinions and experience of our editors. |
1 | 10 |
After spending hundreds of hours reviewing the best sites, Milftastic does not come close to some of the top MILF dating sites out there (like AFF). Milftastic might be one of the worst we have seen.
The site is absolutely overwhelmed with graphic ads for porn streams. The load times make it practically impossible to as much as send a message. And if you do manage to send one, the MILF’s profile isn’t likely to be filled out. She may not even be in your area – no matter what location you search for.
We have our profile set to a local area in the US, so we’re hoping to meet MILFs who are local to us. After the first 10 women from our state, we’re suddenly shown women who are all the way in Canada.
There are also random men scattered around our matches, even though we specifically set our profile to seeking women. This shows us that Milftastic doesn’t sort the searches by men or women.
We’d like to add some sort of positive for Milftastic.com but there’s nothing redeeming about this website. No one responded to our messages except for bots. There are barely any local matches.
There is no way we can recommend Milftastic.com
Do yourself a favor and check out AFF’s free trial instead.
We’ve gone over many of the major features of Milftastic. Now, let’s examine the positives and negatives even more deeply.
- Beautiful sign-up page. Nothing else.
- Every time you try to click a link, an ad pops up.
- Constantly trying to get me to pay for streams
- Impossibly long wait times to message anyone.
- Most profiles are empty.
- Sneaking premium offers into the messaging system.
The Details Of Our Milftastic Review
The profiles on Milftastic aren’t even filled out
The profiles on Milftastic.com don’t seem updated at all. In the span of one month, the women on our feed haven’t budged. Milftastic continuously shows us the same few women, none of whom answered our messages.
There are so many legit options for meeting MILFs that you don’t have to put up with this.
We’re sure Milftastic isn’t a real dating site. It poses as one in order to get you to pay for the streams they relentlessly push in your face.
We couldn’t tell you who was fake. The women in the photos are realistic enough, but none of them have much on their profiles. When a section isn’t filled out, Milftastic writes “Tell ya later.” Every profile we’ve clicked on looked like the screencap to the right:
When the women don’t care enough to write even a small bio, they probably don’t care enough to stay on the site.
If it isn’t obvious now you should just try out AFF’s free trial instead
When it comes to actually meeting MILF’s and cougars who actually want to find a guy to hookup with there is only one option you need to consider, AFF. AFF is the largest site out there that is completely dedicated to this kind of more physical relationship.
The only site or app that can compete in size is Tinder and that is almost completely focused on people under 30. Women in their 30’s and 40’s just don’t use Tinder much. On the other hand, AFF has been around since 2006 and has a TON of women in their 30’s and 40’s (and older) using the site. It really is the best for finding MILF’s.
You can try them out for free here and see what we are talking about. We suggest any guy who was interested in Milftastic to give it a shot. You will be happy you did.
By comparison, here are the best MILF dating apps right now:
The Best Apps to Meet MILFs For Regular Guys According To Dating Coaches
If you’ve been struggling to meet cougars, there is a very good chance you’re just using the wrong app. These are the best apps right now to meet them for regular guys that our team of dating experts recommends. Try them first if you want to find quick success:
| Site | Our Experience | Our Rating | Free Trial Link |
|---|---|---|---|
Best Hookup Site For MILFs | Experience Highlights
| 9 | Try AFF For Free |
Best For Relationships | Experience Highlights
| 9 | Try eHarmony |
2nd Best For Hookups | Experience Highlights
| 8 | Try Passion |
Miftastic’s design’s beauty is only skin-deep
The front page of Milftastic looks promising and the design is sleek, modern, and enticing.
Unfortunately, this is one of those times when we can’t judge a website by its front page. The rest of the website is outdated, filled with graphic ads and popups, and redirects.
Every time we attempt to click on any profiles, links, or alerts, we’re forced to look at an ad of streams.
Then there are the constant popups from Milftastic’s sponsors.
The graphic ads are so bad that our computer probably caught some sort of virus from just signing up for Milftastic. If you check out Milftastic.com just to see if it’s that bad, make sure your computer’s ad protection is up to date.
The free membership is pointless
With the Basic members (free account), you can only do the following:
- General, basic member searches
- Upload photos and videos
- Send invitations to hookup now with other membersYou’ll be able to access profiles but you’ll only be able to see one photo per profile. Unless they agree to unlock them for you, which isn’t likely to happen.
You’re bombarded with sketchy, graphic ads
The only thing consistent about Milftastic is their streams. Every time you click on a link – boom, stream ad.
Every time you try to message someone – boom, stream ad.
And the only part of Milftastic.com that seems remotely functioning is their section on streams. Milftastic advertises their streams as free. But the second you click on any of their profiles, you’re immediately asked to pay.
They also sneak the profiles of these streams into their homepage to make it look like they’re also users of Milftastic. (Spoiler: They’re not. The streams are there to make money. And you don’t have the option of messaging them the way you do with other members.)
It was nearly impossible to message MILF’s during our Milftastic review
The idea of Milftastic is to meet hot MILFs who are ready to hookup. We can barely begin to message any MILFs because of the constant popups and redirects we get from ads. It takes us a full five minutes to open anyone’s profile because of all the graphic ads we’re getting.
There’s also a constant loading wait. The website runs really slowly and it can take a few minutes to look at a profile.
When we’re finally able to open up someone’s profile, we need to send her a message in order to see the rest of her photos.
We’ve tried to send over 50 messages, but only 5 of them went through. The rest of them stayed on the loading screen until we finally gave up.
Milftastic’s messaging system is sketchy. If you look at this screenshot below, you’ll see that we’ve been pre-selected to join some academy website.
You have to unselect this before you send each message or you’ll accidentally subscribe yourself. That’s a lot of effort.
You don’t need any sort of credit or payment in order to message the girls. But you will if you want to bypass all the ads, captcha, and sneaky upgrades before you can hit send.
Milftastic.com’s “Gold Membership”
There is an upgraded version of Milftastic called the “Gold Membership.” Their sales page for the Milftastic Gold Membership doesn’t tell us much about what it’s for.
After digging around Milftastic’s customer support session, we found what the Milftastic Silver and Milftastic Gold memberships are for:
Basic members (free account):
- General, basic member searches
- Upload photos and videos
- Send invitations to hookup now with other members
Silver members (paid account):
- View all members’ photos and videos
- Contact all other milftastic.com members
- Can do advanced searches
- Can send friend requests
- Get listed above all Basic members in all search results
Gold members (paid account):
- Can view all members’ photos and videos
- Can contact all other members
- Get listed above all Basic and Silver members in all search results
- Can do advanced searches
- Can upload photos and videos
- Can send invitations to hookup now with other members
- Can send friend requests
There is only one real benefit to getting a paid Milftastic account. It lets you unlock the other photos of the members without requesting them to be unlocked.
Silver and Gold members can see everything.
If there were more women on Milftastic or less hassle to send a message, we may have tried the upgraded version.
Otherwise, it seems like a waste of time and money.
Frequently Asked Questions About Milftastic
Need a little more clarity on whether or not you should use Milftastic? Here are some FAQs:
What is Milftastic?
Milftastic.com is supposed to be a dating site where you find a MILF or a sugar mama. Unfortunately, Milftastic seems more like a false advertisement for paid stream services with the number of graphic ads you get.
Who actually owns Milftastic.com?
Milftastic.com is owned by I&L Ltd., which is a company registered in Scotland.
How can I contact Milftastic?
You can contact them by phone at 1-877-248-8752 or email support [ at ] milftastic.com
Is Milftastic.com real?
Yes, Milftastic.com is a real site. However, all the users you interact with are either bots or employees. They even admit to this in their terms and conditions.
Is Milftastic legit?
Nope. There are no MILFs here. They have something called “MILF stars.” But according to their terms and conditions, they can be bots or staff members. Or even hired models who message you in hopes that you’ll purchase an upgraded account.
Is Milftastic.com a scam or fake?
While we wouldn’t call it an outright scam, Milftastic.com uses bots or employees to talk to users. So yes, anyone you talk to is categorically fake.
Is Milftastic safe?
No, we don’t think Milftastic is safe.
What are Milftastic.com alternatives?
We spend a lot of time reviewing and using dating sites to meet MILFs. Here is a list of the top hookup and dating sites from this year.
How does Milftastic work?
Like most dating sites, Milftastic is a site where you’re free to browse through profiles and pick which ones you want to contact. However, you need a paid account to send them messages.
Is there a Milftastic.com app?
No, Milftastic.com doesn’t have an app.
How much does Milftastic cost?
There’s no page that shows exactly how much the Silver or Gold Milftastic accounts are. When we click on their upgrade section, it shows us that we will be billed $99 for 6 months worth of Gold. Then we’ll be billed $16.50 per month after that.
How can you use Milftastic.com for free?
There’s not much you can do with the free version of Milftastic. You’ll have access to profiles of female members, but you’re only able to see one photo. You can send them a message to request a photo to be unlocked. But they have to be willing to respond to you first.
Can you send messages for free on Milftastic?
No, you can’t send messages without a paid Milftastic account.
How do you cancel your Milftastic.com account?
If you have an upgraded account with Milftastic, there’s no easy way to cancel your paid subscription. You’d have to call them at 1-877-248-8752 or email support [ at ] milftastic.com to cancel the account.
How do you delete your Milftastic.com account?
Unfortunately, you can’t delete your Milftastic.com account, according to their FAQ. Your best bet is hiding your profile.
We’re not sure if hiding your profile truly hides it. When we clicked back on the setting, it automatically resets us to “show.”
Our Decision? Milftastic Is A Bust
Milftastic is a complete waste of time unless you’re in the market for shelling out money to watch a few streams. You’re better off checking out one of these sites for MILFs.
Have you tired Milftastic? Give us the details of your experience!
More reviews worth reading
If you found this review useful check out these other MILF sites:
MILFs Hookup Review
MILF.com Review
MILFaholic Review
Local MILFs Review
Moms Get Naughty Review
xMILFs Review
