Where You Will Have the Best Luck Finding a Hookup in Indianapolis (Bars, Sites, & Apps)

Beautiful women sitting at the bar trying to find a hookup in Indianapolis

If you live in the area and are wondering about the best places to find a hookup in Indianapolis, look no further my friend. We are going to share with you our favorite hookup apps and sites, as well as the best hookup bars singles love to use in Indy. It’s not that we think finding casual sex in this city is hard. We simply want you equipped with the best of the best in the hookup world of Indianapolis.

When we put our list of hookup apps, sites and bars together, we did so with all of Indianapolis in mind. So whether you live in a ritzy neighborhood like Carmel, near urban Pogue’s Run or even in the small town of Logansport, we’ve got the ultimate list to help you get laid in Indianapolis! And no matter your age, as long as you are old enough to hook up, we have something for you.

Finding some fun in Indy has never been easier. Take a look below and see for yourself why these hookup sources are our favorite in Indianapolis.

Where Indianapolis Hookups Happen

Hookup bars and hookup sites go hand-in-hand. Use both and you double your chances of finding what you're looking for, day or night. To increase your chances of finding someone right now, download the apps below before you bar hop these fun spots.

A group of singles at Newfields Beer Garden


Newfields Beer Garden is one of the best bars to get laid in Indianapolis

If you love a good beer as much as we do then you must head over to Newfields. The beer garden at Newfields is the perfect place to scout for beautiful women. Nestled right next to the historic Madeline F. Elder Greenhouse, Newfields beer garden is very popular among locals. And the more popular a bar, the better the odds to find a hookup in Indianapolis.

Newfields Beer Garden is always adding new drinks to the menu, as well as offering classic favorites. These options include everything from draft to cider to eclectic bottled drinks. When you get hungry you can order a Giant Grilled Pretzel, shareable cheese charcuterie or one of their tasty veggie boards.

Play your cards right and you can be drinking a crisp beer while you enjoy a shareable dish with the woman of your dreams.


Hookup app Adult FriendFinder

Adult FriendFinder is the top Indianapolis hookup app for most who want no-strings fun (try it free)

A lot of people tend to use hookup apps just for attention, but not the users on Adult FriendFinder. AFF works best for real people looking for casual sex in Indianapolis. This hookup site is especially great if you are more interested in a one-night-stand versus dating in general. Both parties are expecting the same thing, so no awkward “goodbyes” later. And the best thing about this app is that you can find some looking for fun no matter what your age!

If you have done any research you have probably already heard of Adult FriendFinder. They have been the go-to site for people who are just looking for sex for several years now and often our primary recommendation. If you are serious about finding some casual fun, especially if other sites haven’t worked great for you, your odds are better here. Checking out their free trial is a great option for you.

AFF has been around for a very long time and has a massive user-base of over 90 million people. In a city of over 860,000 residents, you are bound to find tons of eligible singles who are exactly your type. So when it comes to the sites that have the most hookup choices, AFF will always deliver.

Try Adult FriendFinder For Free!
Using this link to Adult Friend Finder's free trial offer you can check out exactly why so many guys have had such great success finding hookups using it. It really is the best option for most guys that we've found, especially when you're not super good looking.


Several women meeting up at Coffeehouse Five


Coffeehouse Five is for charitable people (who also want to get laid in Indianapolis)

What better way to feel good about your conquest than to spend your money on a place that gives back? Coffeehouse Five is a for-benefit, and may we say absolutely delicious, coffee spot that you must check out. The owners of this coffee-mecca are so passionate about giving back that they give all their net revenue to support their community.

Finding real local hookups is a lot easier in a place that allows for a little conversation. Popular coffee houses, especially those that are open late, are really great places to meet a lot of single women. They're usually open-minded and hopped up on caffeine so don't expect to go to bed early!

This Indianapolis coffee house made our list not only for their charitable donations but also because of their inviting menu. The coffee and espresso options are to die for, and the dessert options are out of this world. It is no wonder so many locals frequent Coffeehouse Five to fill all of their tasty desires.

If industrial chic interior is your vibe and you’re craving a delicious beverage while you search for a hookup, Coffeehouse Five is where you need to hang out.

Cougar Life hookup app

Cougar Life is our favorite Indianapolis hookup app for older women

There are few hookup sites out there that are geared towards helping younger men meet older women to hook up with. Cougar Life, however, is the mothership of all dating sites for getting laid in Indianapolis, and it's the highest quality of its kind. Beyond helping young men meet their older female companions, Cougar Life is also great for older men looking to meet women their age.

We love Cougar Life because the site allows people to pursue a type of relationship/hookup that is still stigmatized today. Cougar Life removes any doubt that an older woman is interested in hooking up with a younger man or that a 30+ woman is just looking for a good time. If you would like to score a cougar but aren’t sure where to start, check out our course for dating cougars with massive success.

Cougar Life is the best site for you if you are interested in hooking up with a woman who’s more mature than the ones you’ll find on Tinder. The site has continuously made the number one spot on our list of best cougar dating sites, and we are confident you will love it.

Try Cougar Life For Free


Our Favorite Indianapolis Hookup Apps and Bars

Once you've had your fill of searching for singles through hookup apps, it's time to explore other ways of finding them. Try out these hotspots and apps to find the hookup for you!

Indianapolis hookup bars where you'll meet single locals

Finding someone who's also looking to get laid in Indianapolis is a piece of cake. Everything from the music to the drinks to the fun-loving vibe makes people forget all reservations. Who doesn’t love a great drink, good music, and hot women? We know you do. Check out the best bars to find your perfect match.

Hit up these bars on Friday and Saturday evenings to ensure you meet tons of singles!

Hookup app Tinder

If you are young and attractive Tinder is a solid option

Anyone who attends Butler or Purdue University needs to pay attention because Tinder is a top hookup option. Tinder works great for those who are young and attractive because the app works on a profile-picture basis. If someone likes your look, they swipe right and if not, they swipe left. It can work for anyone, but it works best if you’re under 28.

Even though this app used to be recognized as a popular place to find casual sex in Indianapolis, it has now evolved into more of a general dating tool. Not to say that you won’t find a woman who only wants to hook up, but if you are interested in more, you can now turn to Tinder.

Being attractive will definitely help you on this app, but just because you don’t feel like supermodel material, that doesn’t mean it won’t work for you. We'd say it's where you can get laid in Indianapolis if you've got the looks and the moves!

Try Tinder For Free


Options you can find at Kroger


Did you know that Kroger is a great place to pick up women?

We bet you heard someone say they met an attractive woman at the grocery store. This seems to be a common occurrence both in movies and in real life but hasn't quite made it into your list of places to find a hookup in Indianapolis. Why not make that fantasy a reality at Kroger?

We think Kroger where you can get laid in Indianapolis for two reasons. One being because you are going to meet local women who are more likely to talk to you if they don’t think you are their scouting for women. And two, a lot of women actually go to the grocery store hoping they run into an attractive man. If that’s not motivation enough, we don’t know what is!

If you liked this check out these other great spots for hookups:

Next - Previous

Join Our Newsletter For Exclusive Dating Tips & Advice
No Spam.
Just Higher Dating Success.

Leave a Comment